Ausoge t1_j0t6ekn wrote
Reply to comment by fliguana in Would it be possible to 'carbonate' a beverage with a gas much heavier or lighter than air, and then when the consumer drinks it, the gas density changes their voice pich? Such as with the helium trick? by infadibulum
Quick note - it is not the speed of sound in the gas that affects a person's voice, it is the density of the gas that affects resonance. Speed of sound usually correlates with gas density if the pressure remains equal, however, so it is easy to conflate the cause there.
Gas density will also affect how Bernoulli's principle causes your vocal cords to vibrate - a less dense gas will lessen the effect of Bernoulli's principle, which is responsible for pulling your vocal cords into the moving airstream - but this is counterbalanced by the fact that it also offers less physical resistance to your cords springing back and forth, and that it requires less effort for your diaphragm and lungs to expel. The result is that more gas volume will be expelled for a given amount of effort i.e. your lungs will push out the air faster if you do not consciously compensate, thereby increasing the effect of Bernoulli's principle. So these two effects more or less cancel out and the fundamental pitch and amplitude of a person's voice will remain basically consistent.
Rather, it is the resonant characteristics of your head and chest, which give your voice its unique timbre, and distinguish it from another person's voice (and indeed from a piano or violin), which will be noticeably affected.
fliguana t1_j0udn7l wrote
>Quick note - it is not the speed of sound in the gas that affects a person's voice, it is the density of the gas that affects resonance.
Air density is lower by half (at least) at mount Everest. I don't remember mountain climbers having funny voices at altitude.
Are you sure about your density statement?
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments