Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

1ToeIn t1_ixkgxwh wrote

Omg. I read this book for the first time just a year or so ago. Overall I enjoyed it, but there was one thing that hit a jarring note for me. I know partly due to reading it through the lens of modern sensibilities. But perhaps the rest of you can give me your feedback: that boy she becomes friends with ( I think he’s a goat herd?) seemed verging on mean & I recall feeling disturbed by the way she tip toed around his moods and in her cheerful way did & said things to appease/placate him. Am I hypersensitive or was there an undercurrent of violence in his attitudes? It’s been a while, so I can’t bring up anything specific. But it did color my overall enjoyment of the story. I wrote it off as reflective of the mores of the times. Did anyone else pick this up?

0

Dana07620 t1_ixkoq6b wrote

Yes, even as a child, I noticed an undercurrent of violence in the attitude of Goat Peter. (Primary reason I never located the sequel -- which, it turns out wasn't written by Spyri but by her translator -- was because it has Heidi marrying Goat Peter. And I thought that she was way too good for him.)

Heidi very much fills a traditionally female role. That of caretaker.

0