Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Pinwurm t1_iu9idg8 wrote

As someone that travels abroad a lot, Boston is an extremely walkable city, and to say otherwise is bullshittery. Almost all tasks can be accomplished on foot. Also, you’re never more than a 5-10 minute walk from a park, and a public square. It’s safe, well lit, and clean.

Even by European (and yes, British Standards), we do a fantastic job. As long as we’re not comparing to London. If we’re comparing to Leeds, Bristol, Birmingham or even Dublin - we’re categorically above.

We have many neighborhoods with walk scores of 99. Cambridge is the most walkable city in the country and ranks as highly as anywhere abroad. We average lower due to neighborhoods like West Roxbury and Roslindale that are more car dependent, but the core city is great.

Unfortunately the MBTA is meh-as-fuck. Even though Paris Metro on-time performance is similar to ours, they still manage to have 2 minute departures during peak hours.

Our Blue Line is pretty normal by European standards in terms of reliability - and the Orange Line actually seems better with all the new trains. Though departure times are less frequent since the Feds got involved and cleaning house.

Hopefully things will get better with Governor Healy. I’m not entirely optimistic, but TBD.

217

AKiss20 t1_iua9xma wrote

It’s not bullshittery to say that because of the MBTA being meh at best of times that drastically reduces the walkability of the city. Having good public transit is part of having a highly walkable city because it enables you to achieve all tasks on foot, aka walking. Having several small cores that are relatively walkable but then are barely if at all reachable without a car does not a walkable city make.

26

[deleted] t1_iub2ut0 wrote

[deleted]

7

rygo796 t1_iub8wgi wrote

The problem of the walk score is it doesn't account for how likely you are to walk to close-by amenities.

If you live half a mile from a super Walmart, technically it would give you a high walk score given all it provides 'walking distance' from your home.

14

MetalForeign4018 OP t1_iublqmh wrote

This is a very good point. I guess that's probably the crux of the disagreement.

1

muddymoose t1_iudbx6b wrote

Im not detracting, very well put... But citing the orange line (which recently caught a literal hefty fire) as a good example of our infrastructure is near-sighted at best

−1