Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

stereoroid t1_iycmacb wrote

I read the books years earlier, and thought they would be largely unfilmable. Few even tried e.g. the animated adaptation from the 1970s wasn't completed properly. So respect to the screenwriters for making some necessary changes without doing a Hollywood hack job on the story.

If you're used to a conventional 3-act structure over 2 hours, I get why you'd think the movies to be slow. But we're now in an era where film-makers don't have to lock themselves in to conventional movie constraints: you just see the results on Netflix as a 10-part miniseries, not in the theaters as a movie.

6

BenefitPale OP t1_iycombq wrote

So you think it should've been a mini series or split into more movies to give more time to characters and story.

1

stereoroid t1_iycosfc wrote

No, but I think you can treat it that way if it helps you get used to the pace. I wouldn't change what they did 20 years ago, but if they were doing it today, it probably would be a miniseries.

1