Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

skunkadelic t1_j1wse31 wrote

I spent five days in jail, wrongly accused, before they got everything straightened out. I can't even begin to fathom 25 effing years.

719

Fake_William_Shatner t1_j1x26xg wrote

I was in a holding cell once that was all plexiglass and concrete. I think the air came through a crack under the door. There were 16 guys in this 16' space. I'm surprised I didn't pass out from lack of oxygen.

It was weird being a citizen one second to a piece of shit on their shoe the next. I mean, I haven't experienced that with any other situation in life. How does that level of toxic and non-empathy affect a person? I could never be a police officer after hanging out with them any length of time. It's like they have blinders on.

Me with my ADHD would experience each day like a year -- so, no, I could not handle prison. Just shoot me.

Also, yes, I was not guilty. I waited 3 years for a trial and I was going all the way and the police officer didn't show. "Flat tire." I was contemplating whether to take your acquittal and abuse served or still go on with the trial. But I didn't want to tempt fate for the jury not to see someone with a badge and think "that's an honest person." Well sure, he convinced himself maybe -- but not enough to show up to even an unfair fight.

291

Squeezitgirdle t1_j1xef7h wrote

Did you know you could get arrested for riding your bike on the wrong side of the road?

I sure as hell didn't. Cop even dropped by my house and dropped my bike and ipod off for "since I was so nice and did everything he asked"

Spent about 10 hours in a cell like you described. It was so crowded people were sitting on the floor still touching each other. I've never felt more claustrophobic before that day.

I ended up with a super cheap ticket (like $100) and over $1,200 in fees for sitting in a holding cell. They even charged me for the apple juice and granola bar that I declined.

169

LargeHard0nCollider t1_j1xoppx wrote

They can charge you for time spent in jail?

97

jordantask t1_j1yn0ys wrote

It’s a little known fact that most jurisdictions make you pay when you’re in jail.

74

CubeNoob69 t1_j1xpc8k wrote

That you DECLINED?!?!?! they are definitely for profit.

77

Squeezitgirdle t1_j1xpjf1 wrote

They gave me a paper breaking down the fees which were all bullshit. And granted this was maybe 12 years ago so I don't remember clearly but I remember laughing at how expensive the granola bar and pouch of apple juice were. Something like $50

Edit: just remembered, the granola bar and juice was labeled as a meal rather than a kindergarten snack and juice.

95

_Unfair_Suspension_ t1_j1z64sm wrote

Literally forcing you into debt.

"We turned a $100 fine into a $1200 burden. Enjoy your apple juice, fuckface. You may as well drink it, because you're getting a bill either way."

32

Niet_de_AIVD t1_j1yi721 wrote

>Did you know you could get arrested for riding your bike on the wrong side of the road?

Not in a civilised country.

42

Fake_William_Shatner t1_j20m9xo wrote

I've always thought it was safer to SEE the traffic coming my way so I can avoid the cars due to the fact that we've got crap for bike paths in our state.

2

Fake_William_Shatner t1_j20lxfk wrote

>They even charged me for the apple juice and granola bar that I declined.

You need to report a robbery.

3

Squeezitgirdle t1_j21s492 wrote

"hello police? I've just been robbed"

"the perpetrator? Oh its you guys".

3

skunkadelic t1_j1xhe5r wrote

Jesus, the air was so thick. And the echoing noise in that place.

During one of the two hours a day I was out of my cell, this guy comes into the block and the guy next to me shouts "you're back" at him and asks how long he's in. He responded "only six months". ONLY?!?!?! Fucking hell.

96

GetlostMaps t1_j1xy1nb wrote

Serious question: Have you considered emigrating to somewhere in the Modern Developed World instead? That experience would make me look for an upgrade.

20

want2kms t1_j1ye6kw wrote

Unfortunately once they’re able to label you as a felon, that option is basically no longer there for you.

32

DFWPunk t1_j2062xy wrote

I'm not sure I can emigrate to Canada and all I have is a misdemeanor for driving way too fast in Virginia.

0

InfamousStock t1_j21hbkt wrote

Felonies are a problem if emigrating to Canada. Misdemeanours are ok.

1

_Unfair_Suspension_ t1_j1x86m3 wrote

Oh please, you must have done SOMETHING to deserve getting arrested. Cops don't just go around tossing random people in jail for no reason!

/s

And yet people still think they're somehow immune from this. I've seen hundreds of news stories where the victim says something to the effect of "If it didn't happen to me, I wouldn't believe it."

Even just shit as stupid as clerical errors or mistaken identity, which, by their very nature, will only ever affect INNOCENT people!!!

You could be walking down the street minding your own business and if some cop gets a bug up his butt about you, you might not be walking away from that encounter just because he thinks you're someone else.

60

bothunter t1_j20q2ff wrote

Seriously -- I almost got arrested for having expired tags. Got pulled over, cop saw I had a book on marijuana and he decided right then he was going to arrest me. He got a K9 unit to "smell" drugs on my car and the proceeded to search my vehicle where he "found" a broken pipe. Then spent the next 90 minutes trying to get me to admit the pipe was mine. Eventually let me go without even writing a ticket when he realized I wasn't going to budge.

Then, despite 10 cops being involved in this incident, there was absolutely no record of the stop.

7

nudiversity t1_j1z23w9 wrote

You would be in some serious [removed by Reddit] territory, and justifiably.

3

BaltimoreBadger23 t1_j1wr0lt wrote

The adversarial process of criminal prosecution in this country puts way too many innocent people behind bars because prosecutors have to focus on convictions rather than justice.

241

DragonGarlicBreath t1_j1x18og wrote

I mean, a big part of the problem is that since prosectors are elected, voter lack of concern for the difference between "we got the person who actually did it" and "we got someone the public feels good about locking up" is just as much the problem.

94

hydrOHxide t1_j1x52ta wrote

But that's all part of the Great American Show Trial. Much like the trial itself is a show to convince the jury of your narrative and give a f*** about what the evidence actually supports. Experts in the adversarial system are likewise engaged in a d*ck swinging contest, with frequent attempts of lawyers and prosecutors trying to out-expert the expert in cross. That's not how science properly works and it makes many a worthy expert reluctant to do that job.

What matters is that the public is entertained and gets its good vibes that someone is made to pay.

22

DragonGarlicBreath t1_j1xhz9l wrote

I'm not saying prosecutors don't exploit the hell out of things at the expense of actual justice, I'm just saying the other side of the coin is that voters are letting them do it. Just like every politician who uses manufactered divisive issues: they're dog doo on democracies shoe, but we long as voters reward them for it, they'll keep doing it. No one is doing their jobs here.

5

4gotOldU-name t1_j1yhy8j wrote

My experience differs greatly from what you describe.

Was a juror in a high profile murder trial that eventually was a 20/20 episode (complete with horrific pictures of "shotgun vs. head"). It had none of the negative things you described.

Perhaps it is very different, depending on the state one is in?

4

hydrOHxide t1_j1ynj12 wrote

Well, as a trained biomedical scientist, I go by reports from within the community and what reports I see.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0015736892730758

https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2019/08/07/is-an-adversarial-justice-system-compatible-with-good-science/

5

4gotOldU-name t1_j1yo7t8 wrote

>Experts in the adversarial system are likewise engaged in a d*ck swinging contest, with frequent attempts of lawyers and prosecutors trying to out-expert the expert in cross.

So, how scientific is a "dick swinging contest"?

Or an Op Ed from the Washington Post?

Both are behind pay walls, so wasn't able to read either.

1

Fake_William_Shatner t1_j1x3361 wrote

> focus on convictions

Yeah, it's like they don't even care about your well being.

Kind of defeats all the bullshit supporting the War on drugs as well. If we actually cared about the damage of drugs, we'd be researching them and teaching the REAL effects in school -- but, that would also mean admitting they don't automatically kill you, make you insane, or addicted. A shitty life that leaves an empty hole is the reason for most addiction-- let's be honest about that.

If we wanted less crime, we'd spend more on after school programs and counseling and maybe a fucking living wage so the single parent doesn't have a kid who joins a gang because their never home or always tired.

Most crimes that are measured are what poor people do, and the things rich people do that are damaging are less investigated or actually legal. Like, donating to a candidate is LEGAL??? That's a bribe -- why are we fooling ourselves?

Most people will never have anyone do as much damage to them as ten days in jail does to a person. And about 80% of the people in jails in some cities are there because they couldn't pay the fines. Oh, we don't have debtors prisons anymore, but, most of the people in prison are poor or have learning disabilities that made their formative years hell without proper support -- and so, most of them are poor as well.

26

GetlostMaps t1_j1xy6vo wrote

Because they are ELECTED. This is why the Modern Developed World does not elect prosecutors, police chiefs, judges etc - only shithole countries do that.

15

Helstar_RS t1_j232t1j wrote

But it's all about stats not just for them but the department too.

2

DecoyOne t1_j1wxstx wrote

Podcasters are replacing the justice system like Gofundme has replaced the healthcare system

215

Fake_William_Shatner t1_j1x36tu wrote

Wow, either I've been made well by a Gofundme, or, this sounds like you are saying it's broken to shit.

13

Alpha_Msp t1_j1xi0rq wrote

If a couple of podcaters can do your job better, you should not have any input on who goes to jail or for how long.

161

jordantask t1_j1yncdn wrote

Thing is that North America police have painted themselves into a corner with how they treat people and how the system works. Nobody interacts with cops by choice, and the people tangentially involved in the criminal world, the most likely ones to give up information, don’t often do so voluntarily anymore.

So, you’re starting to see the impacts of this on their job performance.

Trust for cops is at an all time low so nobody offers up help anymore.

64

_Unfair_Suspension_ t1_j1z5bp1 wrote

Not just cops, judges too!

https://youtu.be/Te0FXDN7kV0

Some guy took pictures of an elderly couple's hibiscus plants and showed it to the police. And somehow, the police failed to recognize it wasn't cannabis, despite supposedly being trained to recognize cannabis.

So they went to a judge to get a warrant. And somehow, the judge saw photographs of a hibiscus plant and decided to grant a warrant for cannabis (WTF???).

So they raided the house and it somehow took the cops 4.5 hours to figure out that the plants they were staring at wasn't pot. And somehow, the cops seized the plants anyway, despite filing no charges.

What kind of clown show are they running in that city where NOBODY in that entire chain-of-command could tell the difference between pot and flowers?????

>"I'm starting to understand why a lot of the public do not trust police officers. And I'm starting to see a lot on TV that I had always thought 'no, you had to be wrong because the police wouldn't make such a bad mistake'...yeah they would."

40

ReAndD1085 t1_j1z3ag9 wrote

97% of cases end with a plea deal where the person admits some wrong and over 90% of the remaining cases which go to trial end up with a conviction on at least one charge.

If a cop arrests you in America, you WILL go to jail and then prison unless you can plea your way to some kind of community service type punishment

19

_Unfair_Suspension_ t1_j1z5tr8 wrote

There's always the chance the prosecutor drops the charges (usually the day before the trial they've spent weeks/months pursuing and claiming to be ready for) because they have no evidence and hoped you'd just take a plea...

10

medfreak t1_j1x96d5 wrote

I always want the death penalty for people who commit the most henious crimes, like this guy:

https://www.cnn.com/2022/12/08/us/texas-athena-strand-kidnapping-christmas-present/index.html

But then I hear stories like this that reminds me that no matter what, this justice system always fails some in the worst way possible.

90

Jetztinberlin t1_j1zxd5v wrote

1 in 8 death row prisoners has been exonerated, and that probably means more than that are innocent.

14

LadyMRedd t1_j1y03gp wrote

About 15 years ago I was a juror on a murder trial. I lost so much faith in our justice system after everything I experienced during that trial and the jury deliberation. I also was diagnosed with PTSD from the experience.

This doesn’t surprise me. At all.

56

EbbyRed t1_j1zsptc wrote

Last year I was a juror on a triple murder case. After that experience, I told my wife that I hope we never need to rely on the police or justice system to find justice. Utter complete fucking failures every step of the way.

It was honestly embarrassing to watch the homicide detectives on the stand demonstrate their complete incompetence and negligence.

18

Jetztinberlin t1_j1zy4q8 wrote

And that was a good trial, because you actually got to see the incompetence and negligence :(

4

BigBobby2016 t1_j1wub3h wrote

ITT - Redditors upvoting something not oniony at all because it’s an unfortunate occurrence that happens far too often

50

Teadrunkest t1_j1yfqon wrote

I think you put far too much credit in how much people look at the sub before upvoting/downvoting.

I didn’t even realize what sub this was until your comment.

19

DM_me_goth_tiddies t1_j1ymdfw wrote

Outside of America this is an insanely Onion headline. Podcast gets men out of jail… what criminal justice system y’all running over there.

12

BigBobby2016 t1_j1yms3l wrote

Does it really happen more in the US than elsewhere? Googling brings up plenty of cases in Europe and Asia. One of the top results is this wiki which is obviously incomplete but does represent most countries -> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_miscarriage_of_justice_cases

8

DM_me_goth_tiddies t1_j1ymux3 wrote

That a podcast overturns them is seems to be uniquely American

−5

BigBobby2016 t1_j1ynomm wrote

Ehh…again googling came up with this list at the top -> https://www.innocence.fm/

Two in US, one in UK, one in Italy. I’d need to see some real statistics to believe this is dominantly an American problem, exonerated by podcasts or otherwise

9

nudiversity t1_j1z217i wrote

I want the fucking prosecutor’s name and address. Why the fuck are people in law enforcement community protected, they basically kidnapped two men for decades. Somebody needs to pay.

28

_Unfair_Suspension_ t1_j1z50iz wrote

Right? Why are these hypocrites seemingly immune to the very accountability they dish out to others????

12

nudiversity t1_j1z53jt wrote

Because no well-meaning vigilante has made them pay the price yet. We both know that the only thing that should be done are the kind of things that we can’t discuss here. These would be old, likely retired men by now. Something like the golf course scene in the movie “falling down” comes to mind…

5

_Unfair_Suspension_ t1_j1z85nq wrote

Hey, Germany prosecutes bedridden 97-year-olds for their involvement in the Holocaust, so why can't we go after a cop that framed someone 25 years ago?

And human nature being what it is, if this cop had ANY brains, he'd be terrified that the victim or their friends/family might "pay him a visit" someday. I hope he's spent the past 25 years looking over his shoulder. But it would be equally satisfying to see his face when karma unexpectedly shows up in his golden years to repay him for what he (until now) THOUGHT he got away with...

10

nudiversity t1_j1z8em8 wrote

You’re not wrong. Although if you’re gonna prosecute the secretary, then there are plenty of American troops and contractors who are complicit in war crimes.

And, I’m definitely not talking about legal recourse in my previous comment.

2

_Unfair_Suspension_ t1_j1z8vpq wrote

> And, I’m definitely not talking about legal recourse in my previous comment.

After being shown firsthand how broken the legal system is, I'm honestly shocked there aren't more cases of vigilante justice.

I mean, why would you seek recourse from within the very system that screwed you over in the first place?? That's like catching your spouse in bed with someone else and then asking your spouse for relationship advice!!!!

The very fact that you need to seek recourse proves that you can't trust the system...because if you could, you'd have no need for recourse to begin with!!!

6

nudiversity t1_j1z927q wrote

Completely agree. The only way to fix it is to fight outside the system. The supreme court is corrupt and broken at the top so why even use legal means?

3

_Unfair_Suspension_ t1_j1z9jbh wrote

because unlike us, they're willing to kill.

Who's more likely to kill someone:

Me with a joint? Or a cop with a gun?

5

Crooked_Cock t1_j20kyqj wrote

They should sue the fucking state.

4

YardHunter t1_j1yjldb wrote

Every day I thank god I’m not born in America

2

ContactHonest2406 t1_j1yl8rt wrote

I’m sure it happens in your country too. It happens in every country.

15

freedom_from_factism t1_j1yw0bb wrote

but how can it happen in the fairest, bestest, most handsome country in the world?

yeah, it's a /s

−1

[deleted] t1_j1x2h8p wrote

[removed]

1

AutoModerator t1_j1x2hdx wrote

Sorry, but your account is too new to post. Your account needs to be either 2 weeks old or have at least 250 combined link and comment karma. Don't modmail us about this, just wait it out or get more karma.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

−4

808speed t1_j1yikm0 wrote

I’ll watch this on Netflix

1

i_am_ms_greenjeans t1_j1ywo34 wrote

Listened to this podcast over the summer, and was so happy with the outcome.

1

river_tree_nut t1_j21l7wv wrote

Brought to you by the same people who elected Marjorie Taylor Greene...twice.

1

drakejones99 t1_j20l65w wrote

"Guilty" doesn't mean you did it. Guilty just means that 12 people were convinced by a prosecutor that you did it - whether you did it or not. That's why I no longer support the death penalty. No prosecutor ever has said they convicted the wrong man/woman. If they took responsibility for their fuck-ups they'd have to commit suicide to make things right.

0

Max_E_Mas t1_j1zep33 wrote

Mmk. My phone isn't loading all the article so maybe I'm missing the answer to this, but how can people who talk in a microphone for hours found a way to release two men falsely accused or murder?

−1