Submitted by atwork925 t3_y2xmgs in philadelphia
MrGulo-gulo t1_is6dw3c wrote
Reply to comment by GreenAnder in Police arrest second suspect in Roxborough High School shooting by atwork925
>Judge sets bail at 170k
Do we know why?
GreenAnder t1_is6ek90 wrote
I'll confess I haven't looked into that, but the judges in the city routinely balk at high bail.
For some background, the DA does support no cash bail but we do not have it currently implemented in this city. That system isn't what a lot of people think it is, basically everyone is either a danger to society/flight risk or they're not. In a no cash bail system you let the people who should be free on bail out and keep the ones who are dangerous in. Right now a mass murderer could get out on bail if they had enough money, while some guy who got arrested for having too many unpaid parking tickets can't.
Like I said, we don't have it in this city. What the DA often does is try to set the maximum legal amount they can if they don't believe someone should be allowed to go free. That's what happened here. The judges routinely deny those requests and set it to something that can be paid, it happens all the time. Last year there was a guy out on bail who killed that Temple kid? Krasner took a lot of heat for that but it was the same exact situation, they tried to set bail at 1 mil and the judge reduced it twice.
MrGulo-gulo t1_is6j1oj wrote
If one good thing can come of this I hope that maybe these judges that hold this position have their minds changed. This man clearly should not have been able to walk around.
lordredsnake t1_is8r4wm wrote
u/GreenAnder 's comment is a good explanation of the machinations behind that outcome. But on a practical level, the judge set it at 170k because people in PA have a right to bail except for in the case of capital crimes (his convictions were not) and/or they pose an immediate threat to public safety. The latter seems clear with 20/20 hindsight, but at the time he was convicted we didn't have Precogs proving that he was going to go out and shoot up a school. Million dollar bail can be argued as denial of bail (because it's meant to be) and a violation of civil rights.
This judge attempted to balance the constitutional right to bail with risk to public safety and the judge judged wrongly here.
GreenAnder t1_isadvbn wrote
My general point is that people think this is all the DA when it isn't, but this is also a major area of complaint with Krasner. It would be very easy for him to get on TV and explain this, but he doesn't. It's not the guys policies that are the problem, it's him and his ability to get along with people and explain things to the public.
lordredsnake t1_isaznsy wrote
Agreed 100%. His retail politics are atrocious and it undermines his stated mission.
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments