Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

DrMilzie OP t1_j9n95z5 wrote

Reply to comment by Anonymous-USA in Honest question, what if we accepted the assumption that God created the universe 6,000 years ago, could this explain away dark matter and galaxy rotation? by DrMilzie

No, not shallow, but it is heavy with emotion and thus bias. I agree with you, I don't believe a god, or the God, created light waves in transit of an event that never happened, such as a type 1a supernova, I think the star truly did explode. The problem is you are not answering my specific question

0

Anonymous-USA t1_j9n9t78 wrote

I am answering it well. I actually would prefer you learn. You are asking a question based on a provably wrong assumption. It’s non-sensical. A hypothetical at best.

I’m not being emotional about it. I am well aware how comforting faith can be and would never argue against someone’s faith. But if you say the sky is pink, I can argue that a spectrometer pointed at the sky will tell you otherwise. The sky isn’t pink and the earth is much older than 3.5B years (the earliest dated rock samples on the Earth’s surface) and the universe is older than 13.7B years (the farthest/oldest type 1A supernova detected).

So any statement asking “if we assume A, can B be true” is no, not when A cannot be true. This is a valid answer.

1

hatersaurusrex t1_j9nao9w wrote

You're not being emotional at all. Projection is a hell of a drug.

1