demonicneon t1_j74p1a9 wrote on February 4, 2023 at 1:21 AM

Reply to comment by KSRandom195 in ChatGPT: Use of AI chatbot in Congress and court rooms raises ethical questions by mossadnik

It’s still very much a tool.

KSRandom195 t1_j74p4uz wrote on February 4, 2023 at 1:22 AM

As a tool I see great potential. As a replacement I do not.

I_ONLY_PLAY_4C_LOAM t1_j74rg37 wrote on February 4, 2023 at 1:40 AM

Having actually worked in legal technology, I'm honestly not sure what this does for existing lawyers. As I said before, legal documents require extremely specific and precise language. Lawyers are likely to have templates for common documents their firms create, and anything beyond that requires actually knowing about law, which LLMs like ChatGPT are not capable of. The actual money to be made in legal technology is not in generative AI, but in document processing and search. Lawyers are increasingly having to deal with hundreds of gigabytes or even terabytes of documents in a given case. Ocr, which is also AI and is seeing in use in the industry, makes handwriting searchable. Advanced search techniques make legal review, the real driver of cost in the legal industry, faster and cheaper. Making legal arguments in court is not the reason why interaction with the legal system can be so expensive.

Fake_William_Shatner t1_j77p3ko wrote on February 4, 2023 at 6:35 PM

>legal documents require extremely specific and precise language.

Which computer software is really good at -- even before the improvements of AI.

>and anything beyond that requires actually knowing about law, which LLMs like ChatGPT are not capable of.

Yeah, lawyers memorize a lot of stuff and go to expensive schools. That doesn't mean it's actually all that complicated relative to programming, creating art or designing a mechanical arm.

I agree that document processing and search are going to see a lot of growth with AI. But being able to type in a few details about a case and have a legal document created, a discovery, and a bulk of all the bread and butter that is using the same templates over and over again with a few sentences changing -- that's going to be AI.

Most of what paralegals and lawyers do is repetitive and not all that creative.