Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

TopAbies9056 OP t1_ixcw3vr wrote

This is the case for those who aren't aware...

Who was Evelyn Nesbit?

She was a model and in December 1900 she came to New York City with nothing but her looks, and became an overnight sensation in the city, she was absolutely everywhere.

While she dancing in a chorus, she regularly met men who offered her gifts and dinners. Being so young, she usually turned the men down, as they were often much older but eventually she got the attention of a much older wealthy socialite named Stanford White

Stanford White was an architect most notable for the arch in Washington Square Park which is still there today and the second iteration of Madison Square Garden.

After seeing her dance in the chorus, White convinced one of Nesbit’s fellow chorus girls to bring her to his apartment on West 24th Street for a drink. Nesbit happily agreed, tempted by the invitation as a socialite was interested in her.

Over the next few weeks, Stanford White, 47 at the time, courted the 16-year-old Evelyn Nesbit and even gained the trust of her overprotective mother. Then, as was destined to happen from the beginning, White took advantage of her

While her mother was away for the weekend, White invited Nesbit to his apartment by lying that there was a party. After drinking some champagne, Nesbit awoke naked in White’s bed with her legs covered in blood. When she cried out, White comforted her and told her not to tell anyone.

Enter Harry Thaw

He met Evelyn some years later and the two eventually got married, but he is said to have been physically and mentally abusive towards her, maybe more then White (poor girl couldn't catch a break) and he eventually learned what White had done to Evelyn.

Then one day Thaw and Evelyn went to a play together in Madison Square Garden. As everyone was settled in their seats Thaw stood up and made a beeline for White. Pulling a pistol from his coat, he fired three shots at White from less than two feet away. Two hit the back of his head, the third hit his shoulder.

White fell to the ground as Thaw stood over him holding the pistol.

At first, no one understood what had happened, as party tricks amongst high society playboys was a common occurrence at public gatherings. However, when audience members noticed that Stanford White was missing half of his face, they began to panic.

“I did it because he ruined my wife!” Harry Thaw yelled, brandishing his pistol. “He had it coming to him! He took advantage of the girl and then deserted her!”

There was a long trial afterwards that I won't go into detail about, but you get the gist of the situation.

554

DepthExternal6034 t1_ixcykjo wrote

Stanford White was the Harvey Weinstein and Jeff Epstein of his day and maybe worse,

rich socialite ✅

protected by Hollywood ✅

Young women ✅

Everyone knew what he did but ignored it due to his influence ✅

a story as old as time.

and he’s said to have assaulted girls as young as 8 or 9 by promising them careers as entertainers he had a list of girls in a red book he kept next to his bed.

56

GreenStrong t1_ixcz7r9 wrote

With a mustache like that, no wonder she became a supermodel.

146

tomcat_tweaker t1_ixd2e4p wrote

Madison Square Theater. Madison Square Garden was opened in 1968.

6

brokefixfux t1_ixd2r7z wrote

Harvey Thaw was just as bad as the man he murdered:

"In 1916, Thaw was charged with the kidnapping, beating, and sexual assault of nineteen-year-old Frederick Gump of Kansas City, Missouri. His acquaintance with Gump dated to December 1915, and Thaw had worked to gain the trust of the Gump family. Thaw had enticed Gump to come to New York under the pretense of underwriting the teenager's enrollment at Carnegie Institute, and reserved rooms for him at the Hotel McAlpin. The New York Times later reported that, upon his arrival, Gump was confronted by "Thaw, armed with a short, stocky whip rushing for him."

197

Freedomisminewoot t1_ixd4d0o wrote

Is this who Buzz is talking about in Toy Story one when he's wearing the apron?

22

EliteKnightOscar t1_ixd560o wrote

Up until the end, I was thinking he did it because White took his wife's virginity and he was upset he didn't get to. His lamenting White taking advantage of and then deserting her gives me pause, but it was probably just a way to get positive rather than negative publicity.

209

DepthExternal6034 t1_ixd7hen wrote

“Thaw, whose persona took on a dimension she had never before seen. Manic and violent, locked her up and beat her with a whip and sexually assaulted her over a two-week period.”

Hypocrisy at it’s finest.

18

Kamirama t1_ixd7q3k wrote

Thats MS. NESBIT, oooh she wouldve been pissed at you.

13

DepthExternal6034 t1_ixd83th wrote

Oh and

“Thaw, whose persona took on a dimension she had never before seen. Manic and violent, locked her up and beat her with a whip and sexually assaulted her over a two-week period.”

Hypocrisy at it’s finest, killing someone who did the same shit you did.

69

[deleted] t1_ixd85ip wrote

Yeah, the guy was obsessed with virgins. He also hated White beforehand.

He even left the following line in the visitor's book of the birthplace of Joan of Arc:

>She would not have been a virgin if Stanford White had been around.

Which is kind of tragically funny.

203

Justme100001 t1_ixd8mry wrote

Netflix could easily turns this in an 8 season series....

17

G-bone714 t1_ixd8r72 wrote

“Ragtime” is a great novel.

20

Asdfaeou t1_ixd8u4q wrote

Was it not the Roof of MST? Or is that just Ragtime editing the truth for the sake of a better story?

3

lilcheezzyy t1_ixddlfq wrote

I still don't understand why guys are obsessed with a woman being a virgin. -from a guy

4

mwsongz t1_ixdgnyp wrote

MS. Nesbit actually, she would have been pissed at you.

1

apginge t1_ixdiswf wrote

The fourth MSG opened in 68. There were 3 before that.

> Two venues called Madison Square Garden were located just northeast of the square, the original Garden from 1879 to 1890, and the second Garden from 1890 to 1925. The first, leased to P. T. Barnum,[8] and was demolished in 1890 because of a leaky roof and dangerous balconies that had collapsed, resulting in deaths. The second was designed by noted architect Stanford White.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madison_Square_Garden

8

Imtypingthisnow t1_ixdldbw wrote

Harry Thaw was a murderous vile person. He brutally beat Evelyn as well as many other women and men.

98

ImpendingSenseOfDoom t1_ixdsbnj wrote

Stanford White actually was the architect of that version of Madison Square Garden, the location of his death.

edit: furthermore, he was the "white" in Mckim, Mead and White which was the most prominent architecture firm in NYC during that period. They designed the original Penn Station along with many other neoclassical Beaux Arts landmarks.

34

metsurf t1_ixdwl71 wrote

Ragtime by EL Doctrow has a fictionalization of this incident. Was she also the model for St Gaudens Diana which had been at the second iteration of Madison Square Garden?

35

katfromjersey t1_ixe0mr5 wrote

The movie was well-done. Elizabeth McGovern plays Evelyn. Quite a stacked-cast movie: James Cagney, Mary Steenburgen, Brad Dourif, Debbie Allen, Mandy Patinkin, Harold E Rollins..

8

SufficientWish t1_ixe2nnp wrote

Madison Square THEATER. Not Madison Square Garden...

9

angrwe t1_ixe7ixs wrote

People were fucking hardcore way back when

−5

angrwe t1_ixe8xhj wrote

I think you may have picked up an extra chromosome during the time it took you to add that asterisk. Obviously this comment doesn’t make fun of a rape. It’s pointing out how insanely barbaric people were just over a hundred years ago. I would say go touch grass, but snowflakes tend to melt in heat.

−3

Space_Fanatic t1_ixegqy6 wrote

I love this show and I've really been wanting it to come back as a revival. Pretty much every storyline from rich car tycoons and unions to police violence and racial injustice are still relevant today. You could almost just swap out jewish immigrants for hispanic south americans and set it in modern day and not much would change.

4

[deleted] t1_ixehk1e wrote

Mysteries at the Museum ep on this

1

azorianmilk t1_ixei7os wrote

The crime of the century!! And it was only 1906!

Thanks Ragtime

15

Johnnytestikal t1_ixeiiob wrote

Toy story, buzz lightyear, tea party with miss nesbit lol. Im stoned sorry

1

FinnbarMcBride t1_ixelpuz wrote

This features prominently in the great movie Rag Time

1

pabodie t1_ixemfrm wrote

She looks a lot like Rowan Atkinson.

2

ImperialSympathizer t1_ixerctr wrote

I know i shouldn't laugh, but i'm imagining this college kid riding on the train from Missouri all across this great country, getting to New York, awed by it all, going to a glamorous hotel, finding his room, then the instant he opens the door there's a crazed middle aged rich pervert rushing at him with a sex whip.

36

lightninhopkins t1_ixev6uo wrote

Harry Thaw was a very mentally disturbed drug addict. Hard to know what is actually true in this case.

2

Tippacanoe t1_ixewzws wrote

Harry Thaw was fucking nuts. A very interesting Wikipedia to read.

2

GlennSeaborg t1_ixexic4 wrote

Not the last murder committed inside MSG.

Source: Me as a 90s Knick fan watching Jordan and Reggie Miller. 😭

0

GenXerHere t1_ixeyxo2 wrote

🎶And everything was Ragtime🎶

3

EarlGreyTea-Hawt t1_ixf20xm wrote

He shot him from the front, 2 bullets in the face not the back of the head. It was Stanford's rape apologist son who spread the common misconception that White shot him in the back in order to paint him with the brush of cowardice. But nope, he walked up to him said "you ruined my wife" and shot him in the face and shoulder, likely killing him instantly.

26

gza_liquidswords t1_ixf2wqt wrote

The Onion but out a book of fake historical front pages that I loved (probably came out at least 15 years ago). One of my favorite parts was that every five or ten pages or so would be a headline announcing a new "the trial of the century". I think this was one of them.

3

Killawife t1_ixf3etz wrote

That is one cool stache bro

1

Sqweegy-Nobbers t1_ixf9xvk wrote

These events are depicted in the book, film, and play “Ragtime” -I highly recommend the film.

2

Carb_Heavy t1_ixfdtup wrote

The podcast Most Notorious covers this in one of their episodes. I’m too lazy to look for the exact number but for anyone interested in a bit more in depth story.

1

Imtypingthisnow t1_ixfe3k5 wrote

Mentally ill? Maybe, but certainly bathed in the privilage of white wealth.Even after his overbearing and over indulgent mother died, his money kept him out of prisons and free to rape and beat both men and women.

6

crtclms666 t1_ixfg5cu wrote

This is an extremely famous murder. The OJ Simpson trial of the era. Or vice versa.

2

Mondiaposa t1_ixfic4i wrote

I read that in racism as : an architect Stanford white (person) lmao

1

Soranic t1_ixfiudg wrote

Is this the origin of "American insanity?"

Supposedly a phrase to mean you're mad at the previous partners of your wife. (Regardless of whether it was rape or consensual.)

2

kambinks t1_ixfkgr4 wrote

Buzz: You see the hat? I am Mrs. Nes-bitt!

[laughs hysterically]

Woody: Snap out of it, Buzz!

Buzz: [calmly] I-I-I'm, I'm sorry, I am just a little depressed, that's all. I can get through this.

Buzz: Oh, I'm a sham!

2

zoidy37 t1_ixfn27y wrote

*sees culprit with literal smoking gun in plain sight

Gentlemen, this man has died under the most mysterious circumstances and the murderer may be hiding among us like a wolf in sheep's clothing!

13

Binksyboo t1_ixfnp90 wrote

Now that’s how you deal with a rapist.

3

usethe4th t1_ixftxjx wrote

I worked in theater for many years, and it’s easily my favorite musical of the last 30 years. The music is gorgeous, and the story and the characters are beautifully translated to the stage.

Sadly it hit Broadway at exactly the wrong time. It won Best Book, Best Score, and Best Orchestrations at the 1998 Tony Awards, but lost Best Musical to The Lion King. I’m still confused as to how the show with the best book, score, and orchestrations wasn’t the best musical of the year, but what do I know?

0

AdDisastrous6653 t1_ixfxwpn wrote

Opposite for me. Was excited thinking dude wanted justice for his wife. Nope, he thought of her rapist as his competition.

But people are saying they killed the wrong dude. You guys caught that white was a prolific child predator, right? Kind of a shame more people didn’t get a shot at him.

18

[deleted] t1_ixgtt24 wrote

I had a feeling there would be a catch about Thaw, and him being a violent and abusive misogynist was exactly what I expected.

I just feel awful for Nesbit.

1

GreenJury9586 t1_ixh1hx8 wrote

Just chiming in as a reminder that there’s no “better rape” and being “drugged” doesn’t make being raped OK because you “don’t remember it”. Ignorance seems like bliss but no rape is bliss so let’s remember to not minimize victims or lead men to believe they’re “doing us a favor” by drugging us first.

−1

ViolettaHunter t1_ixh8d4z wrote

Well, duh! Of course no rape is good.

There is still a huge difference between waking up once from something you can't even remember and being subjected to psychological and physical terror and pain fully conscious for two weeks straight. Which is what her husband did to her.

The guy swho drug women are also not doing it a s favour, they are doing it because they are cowards who don't want a fight.

1