I wanted to find one with the old lady saying, "my fingers hurt" lol

Not likely since this one is like a month old and hanging on my wall, but very possibly one like it.

You have done the world a great service with your choice of cat names. We named our cat Miss Tuffsy, from the episode of SpongeBob where Gary runs away and the old lady thinks it's her snail Miss Tuffsy. But now I want a Hubert Cumberdale of my own!

Great idea! I tried Randy Marsh from South Park but his head came out too big and he kind of looks obese lol.

It is on the wall, but now it absolutely needs a rusty frame!

I'm not an artist, just someone who recently began dabbling as a way to stay involved with/entertain my kids. And this is nowhere near the level of creepy you guys have set.

This is from David Firth's profile picture on Twitter. I did my best to handpaint it. I used pencil to draw it out first (you can probably still see the pencil if you zoom in enough lol).

I loved Salad Fingers when I was growing up. So creepy and hilarious ...in an unsettling way.

Edit: thanks everyone for all the positive comments and wonderful(ly creepy) quotes I'd forgotten!

I see the Pillars of Creation are gearing up for Halloween

Very cool