My takeaway from what you are saying is nobody can do right if they become popular to the point it is "overplayed" it somehow degrades on its quality of a song. I personally don't get it. You know people are born every year and get to discover music as they grow even if they weren't part of the time frame the music was popular. Are we just supposed to throw any music that got too much play out the door because some have heard it too much?

Absolutely does happen. There's things I could go the rest of my life not hearing again, that has nothing to say of the quality or palatability to others experience of such things.

Not to be rude, just find it interesting when people use the overplayed factor in judging or having an opinion of a song.