Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Anthroman78 t1_j3cmpju wrote

Ending aging doesn't mean people can't die from accidents or physical harm.

99

tkuiper t1_j3cnrbv wrote

Everytime this comes up lol. Folks really struggle to separate the fantasy supernatural 'pick-a-version' immortality from the real 'treatment-to-not-age' thing.

Even better than just not aging, it's like cancer. You'll still have to see a doctor when you contract it, even when they find a cure.

31

Starnois t1_j3coiy8 wrote

not if you upload yourself to an unharmable substrate.

6

thewinterofmylife t1_j3ctkmt wrote

But then you're not uploading yourself, your uploading a copy of your consciousness. That copy will continue on, but you yourself will not.

1

Starnois t1_j3eh5tc wrote

Ok, so let’s say you replace one synapse with a digital one? Is that still you? What if you replace 50%, is that still you? Why not then go 100%? It’s still you if you do it that way.

1

ProfessorGluttony t1_j3cp8za wrote

At that point ethical assisted suicide would have to become universally legal. Also to say, if they can stop it, they can start aging again as well.

3

shavinghobbit t1_j3cq42c wrote

This is a big one. If we do halt aging, people will still reach a point where they want to die, as morbid as that may be. We don't know the psychological impact of near immortality and not to sound like a pessimist but I don't think it'll be good

3

JoulestheNarratus t1_j3crxns wrote

For most people probably. Hell, most I ask whether they would like to live forever or not say no.
I imagine those would be the ones that would snap lol

Me? Live forever or die trying.

3

StuckHiccup t1_j3crkbg wrote

Ending aging does mean immortal or even near immortal, it's 300 years, give take. The mice had 3 times life span

2

shavinghobbit t1_j3ctrsy wrote

Okay, so biblical ages. Still a really long time to live and we still don't know what it would do to our psychology

1

StuckHiccup t1_j3d2qgk wrote

Yeah of course but the question of 300 years to heat death of the universe are extremely different questions

1