Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

sharaq t1_ixrqyar wrote

Reply to comment by whys0brave in [WP] You are a teenager in a DARE add. Convince me to stop smoking. by UFOSAREA51

I don't smoke and I don't have this ludicrous attitude towards people who smoke, a writing prompt is not a place for your manifesto against things you don't like.

0

EyeSprout t1_ixryqgb wrote

If your manifesto happens to perfectly fit the writing prompt whether intentionally or not, it's probably fine lol.

1

sharaq t1_ixrz95f wrote

I'm a doctor and I don't even hate smoking as much as you people hate smokers.

1

EyeSprout t1_ixrzu8z wrote

What gave you the idea I hate smokers?

1

sharaq t1_ixs00zo wrote

The manifesto above is entirely about how inferior smokers are as people and you seem to be pretty on board with it, so that's how i got that impression.

1

EyeSprout t1_ixs09eq wrote

... wait, the point was to parody a DARE ad, right?

1

sharaq t1_ixs2ocv wrote

Right, like I said, if that was the goal it succeeded, but there's people that unironically say this kind of stuff and I kind of got the feeling that the post was guided by that.

1

EyeSprout t1_ixsyt4q wrote

The thing I was trying to say was that if it succeeded in conveying a parody of the DARE stuff, then it's fine, regardless of the actual intention behind the comment? It doesn't matter what the person who wrote the comment thinks, that doesn't stop us from treating it as a parody.

1

sharaq t1_ixt1e63 wrote

I agree and disagree. There's nothing stopping people treating anything as a parody, but if the author writes unironically, it literally isn't a parody. I could be hyperbolic and say "we could treat mein kampf as parody, doesn't mean it is", but I think I can find a more contemporary example without having to resort to Godwin's Law.

American Psycho was written as a parody, and is interpreted as such, but the author has admitted that Bateman was a self insert for his own frustration with women and fitting in as a 27 year old (the same age as the character). Its a fascinating character study, but it still bears mentioning that the person who wrote it was fucked in the head. So yes, I don't disagree that a parody can be dissociated from the author, but it also needs to be said that sometimes, people with deeply misanthropic views use parody as a veneer to say what vitriolic opinions they hold while using that veneer as a shield to escape criticism of their strange and disturbing views.

1