Submitted by JohnTaylorson t3_11sxykk in books
Anyone else experience this in relation to book criticism? A number of times in book groups I’ve attended, someone has to attempted to annul another person’s valid criticism of the book because of their gender/race/sexual orientation/social status. “Your point is invalid because you’re not [victimised group from the book].”
Of course it helps that characters are relatable and obviously it is difficult to understand oppression or persecution if you haven’t experienced it yourself, but in my opinion, even the most righteous and noble-intentioned of books can be complete drivel if they're written poorly. In fact, if the book is supposed to shine attention on an important subject, there should be even more emphasis on good research and strong writing to support the message.
Anyone else experience this? Has anyone ever said to you "You just don't get it because you're not ____"-? Have you been reluctant to give criticism of a book for fear of backlash? Do you think this attitude has gotten worse in recent times?
Zeshui0 t1_jcg1r6f wrote
That's not just in reference to books. That's what's happening all over the world whenever you try to discuss or create anything.
EDIT: Although most prominently in the west.