Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

Girhinomofe t1_j69f7g0 wrote

These guys make great sandwiches, have great crass Jersey attitudes, and the handwritten signs in the shop are incredible.

I just honestly wish the sandwiches were smaller. Like, the photo is probably no bullshit what you’d get, as I’ve had stuff with like a pound of prosciutto on it in the past.

It’s impossible to eat without taking half the shit out of the roll, and then you’re left with just a pile of meat and condiments that you need to buy a roll to turn it into a second rate leftover sandwich.

It is probably an unpopular complaint, but I don’t need a Taliercio’s or Harold’s display of gluttony— just knock a few bucks off the cost of the sandwich and give me something a normal person can eat for lunch.

31

stickman07738 t1_j69lvd4 wrote

One of the reasons I prefer Florentitno's

5

LittleGuy825 t1_j6bp6qg wrote

Try Brennan’s just down a little more. I prefer Fo’s catering menu it’s huge and pretty reasonable. But my sandwich there was meh.

1

matt1250 t1_j6a56pl wrote

I see their marketing constantly on Instagram and think this everytime I see the monstrosities they promote. Really validating to hear this from a customer.

5

sect0r_9 t1_j69ikl8 wrote

You can order a half hero if a whole is too much for you and they offer semolina bread. You can literally make 2 sandwiches out of 1 or save half for dinner or lunch the next day. Taliercios all day every day. #1 lunch spot in NJ!

2

EggbroHam t1_j69c1fg wrote

They used to give everyone waiting in line for sandwiches a free fried ravioli. hell yeah

28

RedForman1776 t1_j691t3j wrote

God damn

24

darthpierogi t1_j69r9zh wrote

I get so many ads on Instagram for this place it’s annoying.

21

matt1250 t1_j6a3lwh wrote

Same. The sandwiches don't even look like they're meant to be eaten

17

love2Vax t1_j6az2t0 wrote

They must have a special tool to unhinge your jaw, then reconnect it when you are done.

5

Rpmbox t1_j6oo8ab wrote

Same Their social media algorithm game is on point 💯

1

darthpierogi t1_j6orjvy wrote

While I'm here I might as well brag about my favorite sandwich shop. It's a local sub shop in Sayreville called Big Wally's. Great subs, crazy amount of hot subs/wraps that are called different names, but they'll also do whatever for you. It's a cash only place, but it's the only place I'll go out of my way to go take out cash for. Just be sure to pre-order it so you don't wait there for 30 minutes, they haven't brought back eat-in yet but they had a few tables pre-pandemic. Their hot sandwiches are great, especially anything on garlic bread with pesto. Their bread deliveries I think are from NY? not sure, but it's good.

1

Longtermthrowaway5 t1_j696dhg wrote

Fried ravioli is a Jersey thing? I associate that with st Louis

13

Artystrong1 OP t1_j69c5qb wrote

I d k but I think it should be

4

Longtermthrowaway5 t1_j6a70pf wrote

If you don't know, then why did you say it is?

1

Artystrong1 OP t1_j6a7447 wrote

The style of the sand which. I thought you meant fried ravs individually.

6

Longtermthrowaway5 t1_j6fsu6t wrote

I did mean that because I thought that's what you were referring to that makes it really new Jersey-like. That still doesn't make sense to me though if you are talking about the style of sandwich. I wouldn't say NJ is particularly known for piled high bun sandwiches. I'd say it's either breakfast sandwiches or sandwiches on a sub roll, but not particularly this style.

1

Educational_Paint987 t1_j6a6hb6 wrote

Is it? Only ever saw them here. Just made some the other day. Heavenly.

0

Longtermthrowaway5 t1_j6a6ujr wrote

Yea, they call them toasted raviolis. I don't specifically ever recall seeing them on a menu in Jersey. Not to say they don't appear, but I've never heard it as a Jersey thing, unless you really want to stretch NJ being Italian to mean all Italian related food is characteristically NJ

5

Educational_Paint987 t1_j6ab1f3 wrote

Not at all. it's interesting to know they started in st louis.

1

Longtermthrowaway5 t1_j6abjtl wrote

Oh I'm not saying it started there, just that it's a thing they are known for. I guess I misunderstood you then. What did you mean when you said it doesn't get any more nj than that?

2

Educational_Paint987 t1_j6ac7m6 wrote

Apparently it did. I found italian recipes that called them St Louis Ravioli fritti 😂

1

guardianofsplendor t1_j6aacqh wrote

I really don't understand why people rave about Taliercio's so much. Tried it once, and had a pretty bad experience. I ordered food online, and it took about 20 minutes longer than the quoted time to be ready because my panini was apparently still on the grill. Well that panini was absolutely ice cold when I got home less than 10 minutes later. It definitely hadn't just been cooked. And all 3 sandwiches were incredibly bland. Nobody enjoyed them. I also had to wait by the register for 10 minutes before the cashier even acknowledged me. Meanwhile people who came in after me were able to order and cash out right away. It was not at all worth the hype, in my opinion.

10

Gambrinus t1_j6ag9r2 wrote

This place is pretty much in my backyard and I won’t go there anymore because the service is horrible. I’ve waited 20 minutes at the register just to pick up an order. The food isn’t special enough to bother with that.

7

guardianofsplendor t1_j6aimz9 wrote

Totally agree. I would've overlooked the poor service and given them another chance if the food had been good, but it was just so mediocre. I can't justify spending money somewhere with bad service and bad food, though.

2

Need_Coffee_525 t1_j6bhf4r wrote

Oh wow, now I know this is not just a doordash/Uber driver problem. As a Doordash driver, I refuse to pick up their food anymore. I doordashed there a couple of times and would have to wait FOREVER to get the food, and I was never acknowledged as well, while other customers who arrived way after me and ordered on the spot were taken care of. I would lose money because of them, having to wait so long. And the guys who work there are a**holes. I would think to myself, "If they hate doordash so much, why do they even have it?" But now I know they do it to regular customers too. And the food doesn't look that great imo.

Edit: Error-Changed the word "before" to "after."

5

guardianofsplendor t1_j6bkfeu wrote

I think you probably mean people who arrived way after you were served first, but yeah, that was exactly my experience. And it wasn't just me. There were at least two or three other people waiting for pre-orders, and we were all repeatedly ignored while the cashier rang out all the in-store customers first. I guess they just don't like people who order online. So you're right. Why do they even offer that option if they're just going to treat those customers like dirt? And the one employee I asked a question to was rude as heck. So, yeah, their overstuffed bland sandwiches ain't worth it. And you definitely shouldn't lose out on money because their service sucks.

5

birdynj t1_j6bmbve wrote

As a DoorDash customer we put them on our "DoorDash black list" to remind ourselves never to order from there again, because it always takes incredibly long, dasher gets stuck there forever and I get filled with guilt for the reasons you describe, and the order is always wrong anyway.

I wonder if you were my dasher one of those times lol

2

Need_Coffee_525 t1_j6cmiil wrote

Haha I might have been! And I would always get so stressed, worrying if my customers thought it was my fault. But it's comforting to know that there are customers, like you, who understand.

2

ctannr t1_j6a9raj wrote

I went a few months ago and it was bad. Their bread is average at best, and my veal cutlets were ice cold. And I’m pretty sure one was chicken or pork too. Whack.

9

LittleGuy825 t1_j6bpcw3 wrote

Where are you getting sandwiches with above average bread. Only place with better bread within 20 miles is Demarcos in Aberdeen.

0

Softrawkrenegade t1_j6a55kd wrote

Their sandwiches look good but too big to eat.

6

dakanektr t1_j6abkhz wrote

This place has to be a mob front lol they give away their stacks of deli meat at a price/lb cheaper than you can currently get at ShopRite.

For those hating, this is not gourmet Italian, the guys behind the counter are putting on a show of being rude, reheat your oversized sandwich when you get home, it’s fine, no one should eat this shit more than 4 times a year

4

mbash013 t1_j6aj8ma wrote

Keeping NJ cardiologist in business!

4

shaunalivez t1_j6akh3l wrote

Still don't know how these huge sandwiches are cheaper than buying deli meat but I don't mind

2

Artystrong1 OP t1_j6akmb6 wrote

Simply because they do it for you and they make really good. For the price range you get a lot of food that can be spread out if you have a small stomach

1

Artystrong1 OP t1_j6aknhh wrote

I could eat this for both lunch and dinner

2

shaunalivez t1_j6am5ld wrote

I definitely have eaten their sandwich for lunch and dinner and had a butt ton of meat left over.

0

AnomalousArchie456 t1_j6anja0 wrote

I don't know how I'd approach that sandwich to take a bite without it spilling out in one great disaster...

2

NJ_Bus_Nut t1_j6awlr8 wrote

Just looking at this makes my arteries clog up.

2

_TommySalami t1_j6azl9b wrote

Maddone, that's too much sangweech.

2

shmoobel t1_j6baumo wrote

Ravioli is already plural.

2

[deleted] t1_j6cuyeo wrote

Thats a monstrosity, nothing about it looks appetizing

2

riverunner1 t1_j69no9l wrote

Pretty sure that shop is in red bank but it's not clear where the line starts between Middletown and red bank

1

[deleted] t1_j69nvnz wrote

[deleted]

9

riverunner1 t1_j69oola wrote

I am confused here. The business in that shopping mall and the whole foods across 35 all have red bank postal codes. Google maps says its red banks but looking at maps of red bank, Red Bank pretty much ends at the Navesink.

2

[deleted] t1_j69pm8s wrote

[deleted]

9

riverunner1 t1_j69pox9 wrote

Noted!

2

Lost1771 t1_j6cusfw wrote

I live in tinton falls and my zip code is mainly Neptune but also parts of wall, belmar, ocean, Eatontown, and I believe Farmingdale.

1

ThatOtherOtherGuy3 t1_j69roj7 wrote

Middletown is a weird town. It’s like parts of multiple towns with multiple zip codes rolled into one.

By the way, if you’re checking this place out… it’s absolutely delicious!

1

LittleGuy825 t1_j6bpgzw wrote

Can confirm live behind Whole Foods have red bank mailing. It’s quite confusing but has to do with the post office.

1

miked5122 t1_j6a5bgl wrote

That looks and sounds amazing. But I'm not traveling an hour and a half, unfortunately

1

eggrollking t1_j6aloh8 wrote

My digestive tract is liquefying as I look at the image. I can't eat deep-fried food, or I get incredibly sick for like 24 hours or so. Blessing and a curse, really. If I hadn't ended up this way, I'd probably have died of heart disease, or at least be a hundred pounds heavier.

1

CygnusSong t1_j6an1jd wrote

Taliercio’s is so good, but you gotta unhinge your goddamn jaw just to take a bite of their sandwiches

1

bjorn2bwild t1_j6bie46 wrote

This place is legit. Their sandwiches are huge but they are very tasty so it's not just big for the sake of big.

1

jboogie81 t1_j6cpg0v wrote

It doesn’t get more pre-diabetic than that.

1

TurtsMacGurts t1_j6cr05q wrote

You pay extra for your sandwich to be cut

1

beeps-n-boops t1_j6gcdxe wrote

Not only does this look horrible and impossible to eat, but what makes it "most NJ"?

1

hayabusa160 t1_j6huerm wrote

great place love the food there they also take very good care of us whenever we order. they also do our work employee bbq every year.

1

JZstrng t1_j6a0380 wrote

Mamma mia!

0

Vegoia2 t1_j6a07ks wrote

we love fried egglant but not like that, a version for the true american obese cafone in a track suit. and is that mayo? this is what Vendetta is for.

0

HerRoyalRedness t1_j6acxgy wrote

I’m sold, on my next trip to the shore I’m going to get one of these, smoke, and then enjoy

0