Submitted by Liquid_heat t3_y7s5q6 in news
[deleted] t1_isx28yc wrote
Reply to comment by GrannyTurtle in Man Convicted of killing Texas agency's 1st Sikh deputy by Liquid_heat
[deleted]
lmnjello t1_isxd2zg wrote
He didn’t say that at all. He means if there is someone out there that wants to do harm to Muslims Sikhs can often end up targets because the perpetrator doesn’t know the difference.
That doesn’t mean he condones violence against Muslims or makes any judgment about Muslims as a group.
Edit: I didn’t take it as a jab at Muslims but after reading it again I could see how it could be interpreted that way.
MrRumfoord t1_iszrrk7 wrote
I can kind of see where /u/Vakulum is coming from. You could say, "This is sad because Sikhs are generally peaceful" and you can say, "This is sad/stupid because people who commit hate crimes against Sikhs are often actually targeting Muslim Arabs" and there's no ambiguity. But if you say, "Sikhs are generally peaceful people but they get mistaken for Muslim Arabs" it sounds a little like there's an unstated assertion that Muslims aren't generally peaceful.
lmnjello t1_iszsezc wrote
I could see that. After reading it again it could be taken as “Sikhs are peaceful, unlike Arab Muslims”. I didn’t see it that way but I can see how it could come off that way, especially to Muslims.
[deleted] t1_isxghmo wrote
[deleted]
johnnyfortycoats t1_isxj1zz wrote
This is mostly nonsensical.
SpoppyIII t1_isxs5ng wrote
Living your life hunting for reasons to be upset, even if you feel righteous and even if you are correct in your position, is bad for you.
You don't need to assume a person is mean-spirited, ignorant, inconsiderate, stupid, or any combination of those traits just because it's technically possible to read and interpret something they wrote in a way that is unkind toward some entity or group.
Please stop stressing yourself out like this.
FlyBird200 t1_isyagdg wrote
You are correct. This website is full of this same dog whistle whenever reddit talks about the Sikhs. People always comment that to imply Muslims may deserve the hate crimes but Sikhs do not.
HorseshoeCrabForAHat t1_isx2xnp wrote
Sikhs are a peaceful people. Kick rocks
turd_vinegar t1_isx4y9a wrote
It's true and ironic given the Sikh emblem is a throwing blade, on top of a sword, encompassed by two swords.
I know it's all symbolism, but it's objectively funny. At some point some fairly peaceful folks got together and wondered, "What's the best way to symbolize the sovereignty and strength of our people?" And some dude was like, "A sword!"
Everyone agreed this was good, but how do we represent the duality and intertwined aspects of our spirituality, faith, and resolve?
And some dude was like, "A sword facing the opposite direction!"
SirProcrastinateALot t1_isx7v37 wrote
Sikh history isn't very peaceful...
newindianclassic t1_isxitko wrote
The level of sheer ignorance here is astounding. Read up on Sikh history instead of googling it and regurgitating the first page of results before you go off spouting nonsense.
[deleted] t1_isxdv1i wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_isx3ypd wrote
[removed]
GrannyTurtle t1_it1626s wrote
Don’t put words in my mouth. It is the bigoted louts who make this mistake because THEY think Arabs are bad guys.
I have worked with Muslims from two continents and have nothing but respect and affection for them. (Not to mention the heavenly baklava he would bring back after his annual visit to his parents’ country!)
I also have known Sikhs and many people from other religions in my 6+ decades. I find them all fascinating. It saddens me that many people are so ignorant that they mistake vastly different cultures for each other.
regreddit t1_isxtgtb wrote
That was a stretch.
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments