Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

arguchik t1_iw9rmdr wrote

Reply to comment by Gill03 in I'm looking to become more involved in climate justice in W. PA... by Extreme_Qwerty

Thanks, Sigmund.

2

Gill03 t1_iw9tu8j wrote

You should read some Freud. Maybe this wouldn't have had to go past the counter productive activism point you all conveniently leaped past.

1

arguchik t1_iwa85u2 wrote

I’ve read a lot of Freud. Lacan too.

2

Gill03 t1_iwadx6c wrote

Lacan eh? Are you a Marxist? They have a long history of misinterpreting him is why I ask. I find it hard to believe that you are a fan of psychology but feel acting like an asshole in public somehow furthers your cause.

1

arguchik t1_iwbqyn6 wrote

Depends on what you mean by “Marxist.” Like Freud’s work, Marx and Engel’s work is mostly useful today for cultural studies analysis, rather than psychology or economics, respectively. In that sense, yes I’m a Marxist but not a pure Marxist. I don’t adhere to the materialism/idealism binary. I have graduate training in cultural studies - ABD because I became a union organizer instead of an academic. That’s how I know that organizing can win meaningful material change for real people. It has been kinda fun sparring with you but it’s Monday now, and I have work to do. Ciao.

2

Gill03 t1_iwds9va wrote

Unions have a purpose. A+B=C

Crazy how I figured that out though huh? Almost like I know what I am talking about.

1

arguchik t1_iwe5rqf wrote

Never said you didn’t. That was what you said about me, remember?

1

Gill03 t1_iwe6x9h wrote

I still don't believe you do and you have done nothing to show me otherwise.

I guessed you are into marxism based off your citing Lacan and your blatant belief in revolutionary activism, when Marxism failed the same way you guys always do. One not having a real plan, and two, thinking people are just going to agree with rhetoric blindly. It's why communists had to kill millions of people and people deliberately eat more meat and buy gas guzzlers to piss you off.

Collective utopianism is a failed ideology, it doesn't work. Radicalism creates reactionaries.

If you disagree with any of this go find any video on here with activists "putting pressure" on random people and find me one where people are supporting their actions. More importantly, find one where there was a successful outcome.

1

arguchik t1_iwer2fz wrote

I think I have the measure of you. There’s no point in talking further.

1

Gill03 t1_iwersxb wrote

mmmm authoritarianism. I didn't have to figure you out, remember that and I can safely assume whatever you think is wrong. I don't fit in boxes, by design.

0