Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Parking_Attitude_519 OP t1_j4xu1ru wrote

Reply to comment by Majestic_Hamster_812 in Dutch Students using ChatGPT to finish homework; Teachers aren't noticing by Parking_Attitude_519

Wait how are you catching them? Doesn't chatGPT give unique responses and what hard evidence do you have?

0

Majestic_Hamster_812 t1_j4xuix1 wrote

There’s various scripts you can run ChatGTP through. I use GTP-2. Gives a very high likelihood of being AI if it is, and I follow that up with an in person interview. I’ve caught about a dozen of my students using GTP and they all fessed up. Asking them to explain what they wrote usually does the trick.

Edit: I also like GTP zero. I use it as a backup if I want to double check a result.

1

Parking_Attitude_519 OP t1_j4xw51l wrote

Yeah I did try them out before and GPTzero gives out false positives pretty frequently even saying that my past essays are AI generated even tho I wrote it myself and for GPT 2, it can be easily bypassed by rephrasing a few areas. As for asking students to explain the content in the essay, can't they just read and understand what chatGPT generated before submitting them? I think using these detectors can do more harm than good especially given the amount of false positives they give. But I guess students who use chatGPT to cheat are the types that are too lazy to proofread them so there's that.

0

Majestic_Hamster_812 t1_j4xwel6 wrote

Haven’t gotten any false positives; been really great so far!

2

Parking_Attitude_519 OP t1_j4xx1xd wrote

Well I think it's not a good idea to use these sketchy detectors but you do you I guess...

0

Majestic_Hamster_812 t1_j4y1fip wrote

Hasn’t been sketchy so far, and like I said I have multiple safeguards in place! Thanks for your opinion!

2