HortonHearsTheWho

HortonHearsTheWho t1_iydrfl4 wrote

You don’t actually have to be of the local ethnicity to be a zoological expert in local fauna. Just like you don’t have to be of a certain race to be an expert in virology, astronomy, etc. Seems weird to insist your scientists fill certain race quotas.

24

HortonHearsTheWho t1_ixz8cnx wrote

It’s been a while since I read it but seems like you could go some way in “updating” Marlowe to make him a somewhat more palatable narrator, same as Captain Willard. Don’t give him blatantly modern attitudes because that would be stupid and cringey, but give him enough of a conscience for the modern viewer.

Not that too many people would want to see this anyway.

3

HortonHearsTheWho t1_ixxkvtn wrote

Cameron and Villenueve I think are top tier. Definitely Cameron at least.

As for Soderberg, he’s an extremely capable craftsman and has some real achievements to his name, but he takes risks which means a lot of misses too. Second Tier seems right.

−3