Submitted by inthesummerheat t3_127yi2a in Connecticut

Looking to get a half sheet cake for a party this spring... I was thinking Shoprite, BJs, Highland Park Market, or Big Y. I've had them from Shoprite and BJs in New Jersey before and both were good, but I see people online suggest Highland Park Market and Big Y a lot. Do you have a favorite? Or a suggestion for somewhere else entirely?

Thanks!

1

Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

Turbulent_Singer5907 t1_jegeot6 wrote

costco! had it for my baby shower, everyone loved it. the frosting isn’t too much and the cake was really soft

11

Mutts_Merlot t1_jegg0yj wrote

Highland Park makes the best desserts. I think Big Y is good for a basic sheet cake, as well.

1

Phantastic_Elastic t1_jeghqo6 wrote

I don't know what area you're from, but there are legit great independent bakeries around the state which would be better than a grocery store cake That said, whole foods bakeries are good

4

MenaciaJones t1_jeghyl5 wrote

Just had a good sheet cake from Big Y, half chocolate, half vanilla cake with a vanilla custard and whipped cream frosting.

1

alisa62 t1_jegjhgp wrote

Big Y has excellent sheet cakes.

9