Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

thenewyorktimes OP t1_j9gi1xu wrote

The number of people riding outside trains — which can include riding on top of cars, in between them and hanging on the sides — has more than quadrupled in one year. In an era where social media is so central to status, teens are incentivized to post more daring and eye-catching content, experts said, and videos of teens surfing have gone viral on TikTok. Two recent deaths show the dangers of the trend.

​

Read the full story, without a subscription, here or in the link above.

80

Grass8989 t1_j9gi777 wrote

Anyone that has spent any amount of time on “nyc tiktok” is not surprised by this.

9

dytele t1_j9gieaz wrote

Darwin has entered the chat.

42

xcg1234 t1_j9git0l wrote

Gotta have some nice IQ to do this shit

5

RoguePhoenix89 t1_j9gjha9 wrote

And they still don't give a fuck and are still going to do it.

21

OverCourt t1_j9gjqia wrote

Looks like they took the L train

206

NetQuarterLatte t1_j9gjzan wrote

>Jon, a 15-year-old boy from Queens who asked to be identified by only his first name out of concern for potential legal repercussions, said he got caught surfing on the back of the No. 5 train by the police in early 2022, but got off with a warning.

The warning should ideally be like those anti-smoking warnings and show them some graphic image of what has happened to other teens in the past.

201

Belikekermit t1_j9gk57o wrote

Do we really need 2 deaths to underscore the dangers of subway surfing? My biggest problem with this is that it generates train delays.

44

ukudancer t1_j9gp988 wrote

Nothing dumber than attending a memorial for a kid who died subway surfing and then going out to do the exact same thing a few hours later.

430

HEIMDVLLR t1_j9gqs4c wrote

Why is it okay to victim blame and make jokes about Darwin awards in this instance? The same respect should apply, a child lost their life.

−16

BunLife t1_j9grawh wrote

>Rey was surfing almost every day back then, he said. After his friend fell and he heard of Ka’Von’s death, Rey now surfs only once every couple weeks.

Uhh.. how does this make sense in Rey's mind?

167

The_CerealDefense t1_j9gsv4w wrote

These guys don't. They get views from their high school friends. The amount of social media accounts getting "hundreds of thousands of views on tiktok" is almost certainly a tiny tiny fraction of a percent of accounts

11

pseudochef93 t1_j9gunya wrote

Show them the kid that lost his arm at Jackson Heights doing this dumb shit. Tell them what their life prospects are missing a limb.

Edit: this section made me shake my head

> Rey was surfing almost every day back then, he said. After his friend fell and he heard of Ka’Von’s death, Rey now surfs only once every couple weeks. In early January, Rey and the friend he saved from falling attended a memorial for Ka’Von, where they laid flowers and lit candles outside the Manhattan station where he had died. Later that day, Rey’s friend went surfing on the J train. He hit his head on the roof of the tunnel and had to be pulled off the train, not far from the spot where Ka’Von’s memorial had been held, Rey said. He was swarmed by police officers and paramedics who worked to stop the bleeding from his head. This time, the boy survived.

You dense little edgelords, how do you not see the problem? Mama ought to show some tough love so she doesn’t have to have a funeral for her son.

123

ECK-2188 t1_j9gwbnv wrote

I’m pleased how every few years, shit like this makes the news.

Just a great way to show children the cause and effect of blindly following others.

Great life lessons 👍🏼

−1

DisasterFartiste t1_j9gx8fl wrote

I feel bad for the innocent people who witness these stupid fucking deaths. That train conductor who had to take a year of medical leave….I can’t even imagine. And the latest kid’s girlfriend who watched in horror…I hope she’s okay.

40

leftcoastjimmy t1_j9gyslk wrote

Eh, I think it’s a couple things here …

  1. It encourages others to maybe try it
  2. We should do our best to preserve kids’ lives while they’re young, easily influenced, and lack critical thinking skills
  3. It’s someone’s job to clean these kids up off the tracks, it’s someone’s job to tell their parents, it’s someone’s job to coordinate funeral details, and that sucks for everyone mentioned
  4. It ruins transportation for thousands of people for several hours

I get what you’re saying but thought I’d drop some food for thought

85

squall571 t1_j9gzf5s wrote

Fair point, I’m not cheering anyone’s death but it’s the parent’s responsibility to preserve their kids. Too many people are having kids when they don’t know how to be responsible parents or even adults for that matter.

−11

Ok-Strain-9847 t1_j9gzoaf wrote

This has been done for Generations. And every few years, someone gets killed and the news covers it.

9

MistaRandy t1_j9h297c wrote

ah good ole Darwinism in effect.........

2

fieldysnuts94 t1_j9h3yg7 wrote

No fucking shit, no one needed them to die to know how dangerous it is. That’s BEEN known!

16

[deleted] t1_j9h4nnk wrote

You would think the paper of record would have more engagement in its namesake city than 9 submissions over 4 years.

0

Badideanumber t1_j9h50zh wrote

The new “modern” trains account for these issues I hope. Why are kids able to climb the cars? Why is it so easy to fall into the tracks from platforms? Maybe the city and MTA can help by designing a safer Subway system. Kids are going to continue to do dumb things until they learn, but not if they die from stupid decisions. There will be more of this and the subway pushers. News like this does more damage then good in my opinion, all it does is tell kids and mentally unstable people what’s possible.

−7

bumboclawt t1_j9h5t5t wrote

Nah because I CBF’ed when train traffic is delayed ahead of me for 30+ mins because they gotta scoop someone off the tracks and conduct an investigation. My goal when riding public transportation is to be on public transportation for as little time as possible.

5

Express-Moose-852 t1_j9h5t9w wrote

There’s a video game called Subway Surf or’s that all the kids play are you jump from subway, cars, subway, car, collecting coins

−1

losvatoslocos2111 t1_j9hbp21 wrote

This is incredibly sad but I don’t think we need a PSA for things like this. What’s next? “Don’t put your head in a shark’s mouth” or “Don’t eat fiberglass” How about some strong role models and mental health services?l instead of all these kids racing for a Darwin Award?

4

dekalbavenue t1_j9hcflf wrote

We didn't lose future cancer researchers.

19

ALSX3 t1_j9hdbsq wrote

I just saw massive closures on the Williamsburg Bridge yesterday on Citizen due to “train collision with person.” Didn’t even make the connection with subway surfing till I realized it was the J/Z.

In my opinion, this isn’t dissimilar from the Tide-Pod trend in that it’s a social fire and as long as the dominant message on social media is “woah look at how dumb-yet-cool those subway surfers are”, it’s gonna keep fanning the flames of that fire.

I don’t know what the best way to spread the message that “If you think subway surfing is a good idea, be ready to end up as yet another ‘train collision with person.’” but it’s definitely a sobering reminder that the best(and coolest 😎) way to subway surf is in RDR2.

8

GoRangers5 t1_j9hhcfj wrote

Yeah son, rode the R train to school every morning and none of us considered getting on top, we did typical dumb teenage shit like drinking 40s and smoking pot, not death defying stunts despite the fact we saw Jackass at way too young of an age.

−3

Necessary_Low939 t1_j9hhf5l wrote

They will delay the lines and it hurts everyone’s time. I get we are talking about lives here and I don’t wanna sound insensitive, but if they wanna die somewhere, do it with no people around or tryna get to places.

6

mrmrmrj t1_j9hhmam wrote

"underscore"

Any idiot knows this is extremely dangerous without trying it first.

2

ArmArtArnie t1_j9hjlz9 wrote

I rode the train to school every day as a teen too. I didn't surf on the subways but you can bet your ass people talked about it and knew what subway surfing was.

Just because every teen didn't do it doesn't mean none did.

10

Few-Artichoke-2531 t1_j9hjndk wrote

Saw a large group on top of the 7 on Roosevelt Ave by 52nd this past Saturday.

4

swampy13 t1_j9hlfz8 wrote

This is a problem that solves itself, it's not on society to inform people of something that is so blatantly obvious.

Like, you could time travel to ancient Egypt, grab 10 people, come back to 2023, and show them the subway system, and they'd go "Whoa, probably best not to ride on that thing."

15

ThreepointerFTW t1_j9hm6ms wrote

Is this going to deter teens from subway surfing? The answer is no.

12

pillowcraft t1_j9hmrqc wrote

We should probably turn all subways into bike lanes. No other way to stop these senseless deaths.

−7

MasterChicken52 t1_j9hqp7a wrote

“In early January, Rey and the friend he saved from falling attended a memorial for Ka’Von, where they laid flowers and lit candles outside the Manhattan station where he had died.

Later that day, Rey’s friend went surfing on the J train. He hit his head on the roof of the tunnel and had to be pulled off the train, not far from the spot where Ka’Von’s memorial had been held, Rey said. He was swarmed by police officers and paramedics who worked to stop the bleeding from his head. This time, the boy survived.”

So… this kid already fell once and only avoided the tracks because his friend caught him. He and said friend ATTEND THE FUNERAL OF SOMEONE THEY KNOW WHO DIED SUBWAY SURFING, and then he does this on THE SAME DAY, AFTER THE FUNERAL. Seriously… what tf

23

LeicaM6guy t1_j9hrpt7 wrote

Is that the sort of thing that needed underscoring?

0

pddkr1 t1_j9hshof wrote

At this point, who cares? In case anyone sees this, this is the official NYT Reddit account(OP).

There are bigger problems in the city than people doing this.

Cover the migrant crisis, Rikers, policing, the rampant corruption, the MTA, or more topical, the Ohio crisis and what that represents for people here in NY.

We can literally see your post history on Reddit.

You continue to underserved the public and the people that need you the most. Do better NYT.

−8

Sun_Devilish t1_j9i79kj wrote

Play stupid games, win stupid prizes.

This is a tragedy, but it was one of their own choosing.

4

silenc3x t1_j9ie0v0 wrote

Male teenagers and bad decisions go together like butter and toast. Esp when adrenaline is in the mix. Who knows what any of these kids would have done later in life.

Dumbass comment


edit: According to current research, teenagers make bad decisions and take too many risks because the prefrontal cortex, the decision-making center, is still developing until around age 25.

I'm sure you've all done stupid shit as a teenager. It just didnt get you killed.

1

Luke90210 t1_j9igz6z wrote

Mass transit exists so millions of New Yorkers can go to work and school. It makes little sense to spend limited dollars to idiot-proof the system for the dumbest percentile of the population.

5

koreamax t1_j9ih0o6 wrote

I live literal feet from the 7 train right outside of Court Square. I see these kids all the time on the roof of the train while I'm sitting on my couch. We live on the third floor and at eye level with these kids. I'm dreading the day one falls 30 feet and dies on our street

11

IIAOPSW t1_j9irsvq wrote

It makes perfect sense. Suppose each time he surfs there's a 1% chance of fucking up and dying. If he surfs every day, the probability of making it to his next birthday is (1-.01)^365 (about 2.5%). If he only surfs every other week, then his chances exponentially improve to (1-.01)^26 (about 7.7%). If he only does it once a year, as a treat, for old times sake, he his probability of making it to his next birthday is 99%.

Put another way, if you decide to only play Russian roulette every other week rather than every day, you have in fact drastically reduced the odds that you will die playing Russian roulette. From the outside you might say playing it at all is stupid, but you can't objectively reach that conclusion without knowing how much value they get out of it and how strongly they value their lives. The decision to play might be totally rational with respect to what they want and what they are willing to risk to get it, even if it seems insane to you.

23

tybpharaoh t1_j9iw43g wrote

i met the teens while they were subway surfing the train a few months back

3

FunkoPopGhislaine t1_j9j36qb wrote

The people joking about the deaths of children are vile. Absolutely soulless. “Hehe, it’s not like they were going to grow up to be doctors!” As if someone’s life is less valuable because of their class/hypothetical career.

1

silenc3x t1_j9j3eco wrote

Sounds spicy. Could've died up there touching the wrong things.

I definitely did my share of stupid shit when I was teenager too. I remember one time we were dropping large chunks of ice/snow onto passing trains from a bridge. It got progressively crazier as we one up'ed each other with how large they were. We were up to the point they were like large snow boulders. My friend could barely carry it and had trouble lifting it over the edge. Dropped it right on the front windshield of the next train, the impact was so loud and blew up into a million pieces with snowy smoke everywhere. Then the train fucking stopped in like record time, brakes screeching. I didn't even know trains could stop like that at that age. But it was because it was a commuter train not some long haul train with 50 cars. Then the conductor got out and started yelling and running after us and we took off. Probably scared the shit out of him when it hit the windshield.

Not that wild but definitely poor decision making.

3

IIAOPSW t1_j9j4ovk wrote

Yes. I implicitly assumed events were uncorrelated to make the math simple to understand and simple to explain. Its a sketch not a photograph. What you're describing is an optimization problem wherein the chance of failure P is some function of the trials per time frame n. So if you're doing it n times per week then the probability of not dying in a given week is (1-p(n))^n . The obvious question to ask is what is p(n)? Well we know some properties it must have. It has to only be decreasing in n (it shouldn't be possible to get worse with more experience). It has to have a diminishing return and eventually stop getting smaller with n (you can't get better than 0% chance of failure). It has to be smooth (your skill doesn't change in sudden discrete jumps). The obvious candidate distribution for this is exponential decay. e^{-rn} * (p_0 - p_inf) + p_inf where p_0 is the absolute worst no-practice value p(0) and p_inf is the is the absolute best attainable value. r is just some constant that determines how quickly the practice pays off. Now based on the assumptions so far the probability of dying in a given time frame becomes (1-e^{-rn} * (p_0 - p_inf) - p_inf)^n. The last step is to just take the derivative with respect to n and set it to 0. I'm tired so exercise for the reader yada yada.

6

dontbealuddyduddy t1_j9j4r2t wrote

Incredible how many downvotes you’re getting. As if these kids deserved for their lives to be extinguished because they made bad decisions. So many are killed accidentally, or pushed as you said. In many parts of Europe, Asia, all the trains and platforms have built-in safety measures. It’s absurd NYC still doesn’t. If only people would stop turnstile hopping (sarcasm)

−2

cmmgreene t1_j9jcg81 wrote

As others have mentioned that doesn't work, check out the news archives and kids were subway surfing in NYC one locomotives ran on El Tracks. They didn't scare those kids either, pretty hard to scare a kid that seen more death and poverty at 10. What we're witnessing is society repeating itself and not learning any lessons. Kids left to their own devices do dumb shit, somebody didn't think a swath of kids was worth it, now that their acting out is getting attention, so now let's do something about it. But no really wants to make the major shift to society that would lead to lasting change.

6

monica702f t1_j9jft5f wrote

Maybe if Rey had seen what Ka'Von looked like after he fell to his death? The train shoved him face first into the third rail while severing his right arm. The latest kids photos I refused to see when I heard he was disemboweled.

14

brook1yn t1_j9jgs5c wrote

The teenage brain is a special thing.. We were all teenagers once. Except for the teens and pre teens on here I guess..

1

TheLastHotBoy t1_j9jj1ay wrote

It’s only dangerous if you’re stupid…. Enough to do it. 🤔

1

pddkr1 t1_j9jkz72 wrote

No. We see it constantly on this sub and irl. Someone has to say something.

There was all this talk about the necessity of a free press and the importance to a functioning democracy. Meanwhile their Reddit account is posting puff pieces about penguins and train riders on one of the most trafficked sites on the internet.

I can deal with a fool like Elon boosting his own tweets and doing whatever on his own platform, but the idea that the sanctimonious class can’t even acknowledge the problems of the city or society and then turn around and say there’s no need for consternation, that’s too much my boy.

0

spicytoastaficionado t1_j9jqhil wrote

Legislators should have pressured TikTok (and other platforms) to ban these videos a long time ago.

TikTok, where a lot of these dumb trends originates, is pretty receptive to clamping down on "harmful" content, if for no other reason than avoiding more bad PR.

But it is wild to me how quickly they banned those milk crate challenge videos, but you can still find videos of idiots subway surfing.

2

GrouchyBadger65 t1_j9kmqo4 wrote

Darwin-ism at its finest. This is the result of lack of guardianship parents have over kids. I am sad to see a young life wasted, don’t get me wrong.

0

Zontar_shall_prevail t1_j9krwod wrote

Adrenaline from actually doing it and the dopamine hits from seeing the comments on social media. On top of that you have certain boy's brains at this age that do not process risks the same way other people do. It's a bad combo, but social media is the main incentive.

1

MajorFogTime t1_j9ltlu0 wrote

This is really sad but did anyone catch this bit? I had to double check that I was reading the NYT and not a tabloid.

> Surfing videos resemble a real-life version of the mobile game Subway Surfers, in which users take on the persona of a teen who has just been caught doing graffiti and must run on tracks and jump on trains to escape an inspector and his dog. In an increasingly digital world, the blurring of lines between screen and reality can normalize risky behavior, said Dr. Megan Moreno, interim chair of the department of pediatrics and principal investigator of the Social Media and Adolescent Health Research Team at the University of Wisconsin.

> “It’s really a teaching platform of, here’s how to do this,” Dr. Moreno said. “People watch it and I think, ‘I can do that too.’”

Come on now. No one is using Subway Surfers as a guide on how to "subway surf." The game's been around for over a decade now, it's not anything new.

I thought we were past the early aughts' attitude of blaming literally everything on video games.

3

joyousRock t1_jaew88h wrote

China doesn’t allow any American social media to operate in their country. their internet is essentially closed off to American companies.

Also, the US govt is not involved with American social media companies. the same cannot be said for the CCP in China, which is a dictatorship. not sure why you’re so vehement about defending tik Tok’s presence in the US

1