siuknowwhatImean
siuknowwhatImean OP t1_j93w0mj wrote
Reply to comment by Low-Persimmon-9893 in Is Frankenstein responsible for the murders his creation committed? by siuknowwhatImean
haters gona hate. I thouught my experiment was cool af
siuknowwhatImean OP t1_j93vssv wrote
Reply to comment by Petal_Chatoyance in Is Frankenstein responsible for the murders his creation committed? by siuknowwhatImean
Your argument gives me hope, but does the occurrence of an extremely implausible event necessarily place any witnesses in a stupor where they can’t reasonably be expected to do anything? I feel like the unexpectedness of an event doesn’t negate my ability to act justly in real time- no matter what I had foreseen while creating the monster
siuknowwhatImean OP t1_j93v3pp wrote
Reply to comment by atomicitalian in Is Frankenstein responsible for the murders his creation committed? by siuknowwhatImean
Right, but would the “reasonable person” defense still hold up once it is clear that the monster is conscious (regardless of what was expected of its moral temperament before it was alive), as it was when I turned my back on it?
siuknowwhatImean OP t1_j93uerv wrote
Reply to comment by StoneTwin in Is Frankenstein responsible for the murders his creation committed? by siuknowwhatImean
Even then, aren’t zombies basically a virus? How can we even assign morality to that
siuknowwhatImean OP t1_j93u5wr wrote
Reply to comment by StoneTwin in Is Frankenstein responsible for the murders his creation committed? by siuknowwhatImean
I mean, neither, it literally doesnt know a thing when I created it
siuknowwhatImean OP t1_j93tozb wrote
Reply to comment by Varathien in Is Frankenstein responsible for the murders his creation committed? by siuknowwhatImean
How would “virtually no efforts” hold up in court? Nobody knows that I was glad the monster was out of my sight 😈😈
siuknowwhatImean OP t1_j93t5mz wrote
Reply to comment by Rhueh in Is Frankenstein responsible for the murders his creation committed? by siuknowwhatImean
Agreed- He developed a conscience by observing the family even if he didn’t have one when I made him.
Would your prosecution not be defendable in the same way that Oppenheimer was not guilty for Truman’s decision to drop the bomb?
siuknowwhatImean OP t1_j93sk8w wrote
Reply to comment by DeedTheInky in Is Frankenstein responsible for the murders his creation committed? by siuknowwhatImean
That’s true. Even though he acts like a completely new person I could argue that I didn’t create his brain - Is a doctor responsible for the crimes that a patient performs post-resuscitation?
siuknowwhatImean OP t1_j93rtq4 wrote
Reply to comment by Snoo57923 in Is Frankenstein responsible for the murders his creation committed? by siuknowwhatImean
It’s given
siuknowwhatImean OP t1_j93rkqg wrote
Reply to comment by Varathien in Is Frankenstein responsible for the murders his creation committed? by siuknowwhatImean
Thing is, I didn’t treat my monster like crap, society does. The only thing you could argue I did do is let him escape to society in a vulnerable state
siuknowwhatImean OP t1_j93r1zk wrote
Reply to comment by EchoedJolts in Is Frankenstein responsible for the murders his creation committed? by siuknowwhatImean
fr
siuknowwhatImean OP t1_j93qwwp wrote
Reply to comment by miss_scarlet_letter in Is Frankenstein responsible for the murders his creation committed? by siuknowwhatImean
we assigned ‘expert’ roles like psychologist and biologist. im probably going to bribe the psychologist
siuknowwhatImean OP t1_j93pqim wrote
Reply to comment by not_mig in Is Frankenstein responsible for the murders his creation committed? by siuknowwhatImean
In the book, I was overwhelmed by the physical and mental exertion of my experiment so I took a nap. Just as a pregnant woman is probably not able-bodied as soon as she gives birth, would it also be negligence on her part if she fell asleep while her baby escaped?
Submitted by siuknowwhatImean t3_1157d2a in books
siuknowwhatImean OP t1_j978jkj wrote
Reply to comment by books-ModTeam in Is Frankenstein responsible for the murders his creation committed? by siuknowwhatImean
bruh