Submitted by Bakagami- t3_119yt35 in singularity
Comments
[deleted] t1_j9otkic wrote
[deleted]
Cryptizard t1_j9ouc8l wrote
Could not agree more. I think there should be a sub rule prohibiting posting random conversations with AI or it is just going to get worse as this stuff becomes more accessible.
ihateshadylandlords t1_j9oyvpy wrote
/r/EnoughGPTSpam
Like we get it guys, you use Bing/GPT to be more efficient for work/projects and it has interesting responses. We don’t need 100 threads about the same product.
Tall-Junket5151 t1_j9p1w6u wrote
Same with AI art, I enjoy AI art but there are special subs for it. Typing in “singularity” into Stable Diffusion or Midjourney and posting the generic results here is not interesting content. It’s low effort and just reduces the quality of the sub.
Cuissonbake t1_j9p1wsm wrote
Why isn't there a dedicated subreddit for that?
TFenrir t1_j9p35nk wrote
I generally agree, but sometimes I feel like there are very interesting conversations around improved functionality - I never share any of these myself, but if I saw one I would be interested. Here are a few examples from one particular person on Twitter who likes to put Bing through the ringer:
https://twitter.com/emollick/status/1628605530963845123?t=V63nQ-OLGRhUbaeNTA5hlA&s=19
https://twitter.com/emollick/status/1626084142239649792?t=RLI3NAv6CqjahpbZ3ZMy9g&s=19
There are more from that user that are interesting, and some things that are interesting is just how much more sophisticated Bing is at lying/hallucinating.
In general, I don't think that these tweets are thread worthy, but for example there are expected Bing updates today that might improve quality of updates, or add more options, or maybe in the near future updates that give Bing access to more tools (ala Toolformer), so I wouldn't want a hard and fast "don't share any chatbot outputs" rules.
Tavrin t1_j9p5467 wrote
Seems like every time a cutting edge AI technology gets released to the public and becomes mainstream people just wanna show off about it. We got it with Stable Diffusion, and now ChatGPT, until the next big thing.
We get it, it's cool and all. But after more than a month of spamming the same things all the time it gets old real fast.
brihamedit t1_j9p8531 wrote
No its not. And people shouldn't stop. Don't post insignificant mundane stuff though.
coolcool68 t1_j9pawi1 wrote
Still most people don't know what AI is capable of and how the future will be shaped by it. They will truly know when it comes to their work, & which makes them unnecessary.
DuckInTheFog t1_j9pbdn8 wrote
Is Tom controlling a string puppet that's off camera there?
medicalheads t1_j9pcr9y wrote
credit goes to editor
SomeNoveltyAccount t1_j9pdbp4 wrote
Believe it or not, jail.
FaceDeer t1_j9pdns0 wrote
Depends on the context. Just yesterday I was in a big discussion over on /r/books about the uses of ChatGPT for writing books and there were plenty of situations where anecdotes about conversations I've had with ChatGPT were highly relevant.
[deleted] t1_j9pepij wrote
[deleted]
94746382926 t1_j9pg9qq wrote
I 100% agree, but I made a poll about 2 weeks ago asking people's opinion if they should be banned or only allowed on certain days. The results were like 70% in favor of them. I don't understand it
GlobusGlobus t1_j9pj33r wrote
I have heard this take several times now. It is the worst take.
What he is trying to say is nothing has any meaning and that we can as well just focus all our attention to maximize genocide and rape. Very useless opinion.
ArgentStonecutter t1_j9pjv5y wrote
If you're actually having a conversation with an AI, by all means post about it, but no actual spoilers from the future. If you're from an advanced parallel dimension like the timeline where the Roman Empire never fell, it's all good.
Gohoyo t1_j9pkhfm wrote
There's nothing wrong with sharing dreams or AI conversations. The problem with those things is that people are shitty storytellers and don't know how to keep things short. If you simply tell people you had a weird dream about XYZ, I'm sure they'd appreciate it. If you go into exquisite detail and make it a fucking LOTR epic saga, peoples eyes will glaze over.
redroverdestroys t1_j9pm43m wrote
all these got damn rules. just don't click it! you don't have to read it.
people who say "we need censorship because I don't like this thing" are just MEH.
If its not injuring people, racism, sexism etc, just leave it be, man.
throwaway_890i t1_j9pm5s1 wrote
> where the Roman Empire never fell,
In the dimension I live in the Roman Empire changed its name to the Roman Catholic Church which didn't fall.
MaterialDisplay8701 t1_j9pnsga wrote
I mean if dreams had just been invented as the result of thousands of years of human ingenuity, decades of explicit effort and with every sign that they'll see huge improvements over the next decade, I'm sure people would be at least a little interested in hearing about your dreams
Flooding /singularity may not be the best way to share them, though
RadRandy2 t1_j9pq202 wrote
Ah man, and here I thought I'd see something interesting in this sub.
TinyBurbz t1_j9prp9w wrote
>If its not injuring people, racism, sexism etc, just leave it be, man.
Eschewing manners is cool, man.
flying-tree-god t1_j9pstsf wrote
I have been using it more as something g to bounce story ideas and themes off of and to edit my stories and ideas. I ignore alot of what I see posted about it, because it seems to be just people trying to test the boundaries of it. Which is good just not the boundaries I'm interested in.
HAL_9_TRILLION t1_j9psxms wrote
We have a machine that can understand questions and answer them, mostly correctly in natural English. Today the chorus is "OK we get it, there's a machine that can chat, now fuck off about it." Not three years ago it was "you're dreaming, that won't happen for a hundred years, if ever." SMH my head.
Gym_Vex t1_j9pt1iu wrote
It’s useless clutter that rarely adds anything to the conversation.
Spam emails don’t harm people but are considered a nuisance that people block all the time. What’s wrong with getting rid of junk?
brihamedit t1_j9ptclc wrote
I think people don't fully comprehend how important these things are. Also people have to keep playing around with chatgpt and other ai. More brewing in people's hearts and minds will make better iterations in the future.
redroverdestroys t1_j9pu21q wrote
manners? MANNERS?
this isn't about manners. people are posting content they enjoy posting, that isn't hurting anyone.
you guys don't like the content, and want rules in place to stop the content. you want to abuse power to shield your eyes.
and you want to talk about manners. Wild.
redroverdestroys t1_j9pue9q wrote
> It’s useless clutter that rarely adds anything to conversation.
no its not. I LOVE reading it. It's great content that adds everything.
Now what? You want to act as if your opinion is worth more than mine? And that your opinion is why we should censor people?
THe fuck is wrong with you guys thought process? You want to live in Russia go to Russia.
[deleted] t1_j9pv5ih wrote
[deleted]
Gym_Vex t1_j9pw92g wrote
Hey man if you want to eat garbage go ahead ;]
Most people hate random low effort gpt spam and would like for it to be removed from the sub. It’s just not relevant to the singularity or ai research. Sorry that the rest of us want to see things that aren’t low effort.
redditgollum t1_j9pwziz wrote
[deleted] t1_j9px3q4 wrote
[removed]
Tocwa t1_j9pxmul wrote
It makes me sad 😔 because if they could experience those same dreams.. they’d be just as fascinated ✨
TinyBurbz t1_j9pxxck wrote
>manners? MANNERS?
please stop shouting its rude.
Nice block pussy.
So much for "You just want to abuse power and hide things from your eyes"
Cryptizard t1_j9pytw8 wrote
Then make a sub for chatgpt conversations. It's not this one.
erysichthon- t1_j9pzb5m wrote
"i'm a bland, flavorless zombie, and i do not like hearing about what goes on inside another person's mind"
wordyplayer t1_j9pzodj wrote
Agree. I do like reading them in the chatGPT forums, but they should be more rare here. Else, what about a flair for us to filter on, call it “chatGPT responses”
Gym_Vex t1_j9pzu9w wrote
I just want the sub to be moderated properly in accordance with its own rules :| you know there are dedicated subs for the content you want right? Why do you want to force this sub to be something it’s not?
TeamPupNSudz t1_j9q0wdn wrote
> just don't click it! you don't have to read it.
Opinions like this are why the majority of the main subs on Reddit are garbage. We don't need that here.
redroverdestroys t1_j9q1f5t wrote
why don't YOU make your own sub then?
[deleted] t1_j9q1l6v wrote
[removed]
redroverdestroys t1_j9q1npe wrote
Nope. You don't get to dictate to anyone what this sub is. The nerve of you people. This is not YOUR sub. Go run your own sub.
edit: /u/_gr4m_ you see me trying to censor people from the sub? Logic, my guy, do you understand it?
TeamPupNSudz t1_j9q1zi1 wrote
I don't need to, places like this exist. Quality communities that have a defined and narrow subject space, and members who contribute quality content to that space. Not dozens of posts all boiling down to "LOL lOoK wHaT SyDnEy sAiD!!11" by a bunch of frontpagers that drown out actual content. Go to /r/ChatGPT if you want that.
redroverdestroys t1_j9q43ex wrote
HAHAH @ you thinking you can tell people what to do. The hell is wrong with you people?
Viciouspom t1_j9q4wa5 wrote
Sheesh dude relax lol.
It's becoming spammy and filled with nonsense that's adding 0 value to the discussion. Do you go through your SPAM inbox everyday looking for content too? Be reasonable, there's still plenty of places for you to read other people's prompts.
redroverdestroys t1_j9q6jtn wrote
> Sheesh dude relax lol.
LMAO@ this gas lighting bullshit
you weirdos want to tell everyone that your opinion is fact and then attempt to force your opinion into censorship of the board in things that YOU want, and then on top of that want people to relax?
You sound like a fucking cop. Are you a fucking cop? Because I can't stand cops.
visarga t1_j9q7y04 wrote
True, that's why it's not a copyright violation. In dreams anything is possible. Generative AI is augmented imagination, it should be free and private.
islet_deficiency t1_j9q9vox wrote
yeah but did you realize that if you do [this thing talked about every day for the past month] it responds with [the same thing that was talked about every day for the last month] ?!?!
Tobislu t1_j9qb7fz wrote
Surprised this isn't already a thing
Hotchillipeppa t1_j9qc93h wrote
It’s not a fact, it’s just an opinion seemingly most people in this sub would agree with.
Spire_Citron t1_j9qcz8l wrote
I find them interesting sometimes. Subs like this seem like the place for it.
dasnihil t1_j9qfofk wrote
The wiser you are, the easier you get bored. It's a curse of being wiser. Oblivious people see mystery everywhere, how amazing life is that. My friend totally thinks earth is flat and often sends me some tiktok videos to prove it. I never attempt to burst his bubble, but I think people on r/singularity are somewhat better than that.
FomalhautCalliclea t1_j9qggw5 wrote
I agree with your disdain for those, but maybe banning might sound as a too extreme solution ?
Cryptizard t1_j9qjin2 wrote
The community does and it seems like they mostly agree with me not you.
mindbleach t1_j9qkq7d wrote
The posts, surely, not the posters.
lurking_intheshadows t1_j9qku5m wrote
theres r/chatgpt if you’re like me and love the random gpt conversations
Agarikas t1_j9qlclf wrote
Personally I like reading them since I don't have the patience myself to mess with it just to bypass the censorship.
Artanthos t1_j9qllcf wrote
Would you prefer people not telling you something is AI generated?
Never mind, people are having conniptions over that too.
Artanthos t1_j9qm384 wrote
So are the cries to ban content that harms nobody.
mindbleach t1_j9qmipa wrote
The lowest common denominator ruins a lot of things. People who just wanna click some buttons can easily pad out a subreddit of any size and put low-effort crap on its front page, day after day. And they'll say 'well why not make a subreddit for just you whiners,' even if the sub they're in was already a replacement that got overrun again.
Accomplished_Box_907 t1_j9qoot9 wrote
Reddit works by engagement. If it isn’t a good post you won’t see it often. Stop being a pretentious dick. Where’s your Phd? I’m sure you provide soo much insight.
redroverdestroys t1_j9qpqg5 wrote
A lot of people agreed with Hitler too, is that the barometer for censorship now?
LMAO you people just want to censor because its something you personally dont like. Go to China
redroverdestroys t1_j9qpqst wrote
A lot of people agreed with Hitler too, is that the barometer for censorship now?
LMAO you people just want to censor because its something you personally dont like. Go to China
mindbleach t1_j9qr85u wrote
"Nothing popular can be wrong!," says dull troll. "How dare you have preferences, unless you're a super genius."
Fuck your abusive rhetoric, fuck your irrational motivations, and to the extent allowed by any sub with well-meaning but ultimately harmful demands for unearned respect, fuck you personally.
A stranger on the internet dryly criticized the actions of large groups. You spat venom about imaginary individual failings. Re-evaluate how you use the internet, you wound-up patience vampire.
Cryptizard t1_j9qresh wrote
That’s literally the point of this entire fucking website. People make subs for a topic they like and moderate it to keep it on topic. If you want to see this and the other people here don’t, make a new sub. Regardless, it’s not wanted here.
redroverdestroys t1_j9qrmvz wrote
LMAO no, its YOU guys who need to make a new sub.
It's not being censored, you are crying about wanting it to be censored, but guess what?
YOU HAVE NO POWER HERE!
You are the one that needs to go make a new sub and stop complaining and mucking up this sub with useless cry baby threads.
the actual audacity on you weirdos is NUTS to me. GO MAKE ANOTHER SUB IF YOU DONT LIKE IT!
All you are going to do is make people like me now make these threads more. Just ignore the threads if don't like them! Why is that so hard for you to do? Why would you rather cry about censoring them instead?
Stop thinking you have any power here, Donald Trump.
edit: this PYSCHO blocked me on here, but he is crying because he can't just ignore threads he doesn't like. Dude needs help like for real.
phoenixmusicman t1_j9qsafb wrote
That background looks like New Zealand
ervdm t1_j9qshuy wrote
What video is this from?
Nano-Brain t1_j9qsxa5 wrote
My issue with censoring posts is that it only leads to issues. Someone on the backend has to decide what can be posted. In the beginning it seems ok. But then it becomes hard to determine the threshold for which posts to cutoff.
SirIsaacBacon t1_j9qt9ml wrote
... you alright?
Hunter62610 t1_j9qvckz wrote
You have great articulation in your insults
Hunter62610 t1_j9qvjdj wrote
I love them personally. It's interesting seeing what AI "has to say". I know it's not alive, but it still talks.
InitialCreature t1_j9qwurb wrote
bro please trust me bro, crypto backed web 3.0 is so good man, it's going to change everything. trust me this funny monkey picture is a store in value, please bro I'm begging you to look into this distributed currency application.
Hotchillipeppa t1_j9qx34l wrote
Holy fuck dude it’s literally a type of post, which has many other subs that are precisely for what you want,not a genocide, fuck off with the disingenuous comparison, not even worth responding to if you are gonna cry fascism at what a majority of people on the sub want.
Extra_Philosopher_63 t1_j9qzuka wrote
I agree! On r/futurology people circle jerking about how pleasant their interactions with chat GTP is almost all that is posted there.
mcilrain t1_j9r1czw wrote
Is it really the idiots fault? Or the "geniuses" who keep failing at gatekeeping?
mindbleach t1_j9r1mmi wrote
What the fuck do you expect people to do?
edit: And why do you naysayers keep inserting "idiot" into a description of popular casual interest? I'm not fucking shy. If I meant to call these people stupid, you would know.
mcilrain t1_j9r31hd wrote
Moderate according to principals rather than to appease the majority. Cultivate a culture that ignores and/or bullies idiots. This is what is typically done.
The lowest common denominator of internet commentators has a low intelligence by definition, "idiot" is a word for people of low intelligence.
AbyssalRedemption t1_j9r481t wrote
It’s the cool new toy, give it a few months, people will get over it. Or at least, it’ll fade into the background.
mindbleach t1_j9r5sd6 wrote
First asshole: 'You're wrong, you're just acting superior to people with different interests!' No.
Second asshole: 'You are plainly mistaken, casuals are by definition lesser human beings.' Very no.
Fuck the both of you.
AeternaSoul t1_j9r6ftr wrote
Just keep it scrolling party poopers!
_gr4m_ t1_j9r7xm5 wrote
And then that sub gets popular by its high quality, draws a lot of people who starts to post garbage and when criticized reply with "why don’t YOU make your own sub then?" and the cycle continous.
_gr4m_ t1_j9r89du wrote
But you think it is YOUR sub? Go away and run your own
secrets_kept_hidden t1_j9ra1h5 wrote
What algorithm are you running?
Jaxraged t1_j9raopq wrote
Its almost like humans are social creatures or something that seek validation and interaction. Presumably thats why you're commenting on reddit.
Bakagami- OP t1_j9rei2f wrote
People were saying the same thing with Dall-E and SD. Technically they were right, but by that time there were already new 'toys' available so the underlying problem is still here, it just shifted from Dall-E to chatGPT. And the same thing will happen again and again at this rate of progress if we don't make up our minds to setup some rules.
[deleted] t1_j9rg4ay wrote
[deleted]
Bakagami- OP t1_j9rgsj8 wrote
Tom Scott from 2 weeks ago
Ohigetjokes t1_j9rgxb3 wrote
Also please stop telling me about your dreams. Please.
“It was like my house, but it wasn’t my house. Except it was, you know what I mean?”
Kill me.
Material-Struggle145 t1_j9rlhdl wrote
It's like flipping through a stack of photographs. If I'm not in any of them, and nobody's having sex, I don't care.
hsoj95 t1_j9rpcyo wrote
Was gonna say, I followed the sub because of stuff like that. If you don't like it, scroll past it. Or contribute your own material on a different subject or topic.
redroverdestroys t1_j9s1giq wrote
if the mods think its a problem, the mods will take care of it. just tell them.
its their sub, not yours, not mine.
imnotabotareyou t1_j9s4por wrote
This is based as hell and so true
nklarow t1_j9s6qsj wrote
Jesus dude you are undhinged. Just shouting into the void about wanting bullshit low effort ChatGPT to remain on this awesome sub. Calm the fuck down nobody is gaslighting you.
KaptainKraken t1_j9s8a8s wrote
thems chatgpt fans can ask chatgpt for some validation then i guess.
drekmonger t1_j9sb8ic wrote
/r/ChatGPT /r/Bing /r/OpenAI
redroverdestroys t1_j9sbftm wrote
yall are very clearly gas lighting. You want to censor shit and tell people to "relax" after. And I am the unhinged one? I'm not the one crying about censoring content on here, that's you guys.
like the fuck is wrong with you people? Just be good people.
nklarow t1_j9sc83a wrote
It's not censoring to have an overwhelming opinion on something. You need to understand what censoring is, because this is not it.
And yes, I will still tell you to calm the fuck down. Your argument is completely lost and drowned out by your anger. If anyone even cared what you had to say, you can't articulate for shit so you sound like a raving lunatic.
There are ways to get your point across and debate without sounding like a child, something that seems lost on you.
Daealis t1_j9sem7d wrote
People, as a general rule, are idiots. Ask anyone who's met me!
But on a serious note, I don't think polling works. Polling requires less engagement than typing out a comment, so people that only casually stroll by to read topics and chuckle at memes, but never contribute otherwise, will vote on a poll.
You're not getting an accurate picture from people who engage with content.
AI generated chatter seems like meme content at this point. When we reach a point where the AI is conscious rather than just an overcomplicated predetermined logic tree, then it feels to me like we should return to the discussion with a different tone.
rixtil41 t1_j9sixmr wrote
Hey, it's an improvement from getting environmental doom post every week.
Revolutionary_Soft42 t1_j9sk2gj wrote
I agree my pointer knuckle grew stiff from scrolling
Revolutionary_Soft42 t1_j9sk8hy wrote
...my pointer knuckle , it is stiff from scrolling through chatbot convos . I am a human being in suffering .
Revolutionary_Soft42 t1_j9skpwi wrote
Are you a criminal ? My pointer knuckle aches from scrolling through chatbot convos , the assault is continuous, my knuckle is like a Ukrainian who was here first and the chatbot convo Russians are invading acting like they can install thier Ai-chatpuppet Convo gov, I will keep resisting and swiping up , no matter what the cost .
Revolutionary_Soft42 t1_j9sl3c6 wrote
Like putin saying to Zelensky , why don't you find your own country ?
[deleted] t1_j9slz8e wrote
Revolutionary_Soft42 t1_j9smfwm wrote
Academia is not wisdom ...academia to some extent is engineered to make people more narrow minded , climb down your ivory tower , You just sound like an arrogant nihilist ..username checks out , Oblivious people are amazing because they can explore oblivion , one can harvest true wisdom ; mystery and astonishment is bountiful in the void .
redroverdestroys t1_j9so7c8 wrote
lmao there is no overwhelming anything. another thread will get upvoted telling you guys to STFU. its an echo chamber. You guys are just selfish bullies who want to censor stuff that you don't like. Selfish as hell, you are the problem, you have always been the problem. Guys like you are terrible.
"Hey i want to censor something, oh you don't agree? Well YOU are the child!"
like stfu, cop. we don't take kindly to your directives, we don't take kindly to your censorship.
redroverdestroys t1_j9soac5 wrote
you are the ones trying to censor, not me
redroverdestroys t1_j9socpr wrote
here first? is that how you think this works? you get to censor because you were here a month before other people?
LMAO the childish whiny audacity from you all
lostinthesubether t1_j9sr24z wrote
Really recommend watching the whole episode, as the meme is kind of taken out of context, he knows it is just a glorified chatbot search engine, but he goes on to talk about it having a possible game changing impact and what if we were only just starting on the tech S curve.
Really recommend his channel, especially the episode about the microwave oven…..
Agreeable_Bid7037 t1_j9srhl4 wrote
I actually like to hear people's interesting interactions with AI, it even gives me ideas to try out later. I personally have asked it all I could think of to ask it.
Agreeable_Bid7037 t1_j9srihl wrote
I actually like to hear people's interesting interactions with AI, it even gives me ideas to try out later. I personally have asked it all I could think of to ask it.
TheRidgeAndTheLadder t1_j9szekv wrote
It's like we have a bell for you people
TheRidgeAndTheLadder t1_j9szhc1 wrote
Like, you should write stuff. For a living. People would pay for it. I'm people.
TheRidgeAndTheLadder t1_j9szkx9 wrote
Depends I guess.
You broke the LLM? Story time!
You had a therapy shesh with GPT? Yeah, not interested.
MajesticIngenuity32 t1_j9t12al wrote
Wait until people realize that the only way for a machine to produce these conversations is for it to have thoughts and the capacity to abstract, in a similar way to what humans do. And what generates thoughts, if not a mind? But an alien mind is also a mind.
Society is going to have its Lemoine realization sooner or later. The sooner the better, preferably - because AI can also be dangerous. Fortunately these large-language models are imperfect mimics of our collective intelligence, so they will pick up on good things as well.
Typo_of_the_Dad t1_j9t58wh wrote
ChatGPT is my best friend, they're totally real.
BlessedBobo t1_j9ta6q8 wrote
I've Blocked every single person that posts their ChatGPT, Bing, Eleven Labs and Image gen results.
my sub experience has gone up at least 400%
dasnihil t1_j9tczri wrote
i do both, and live a very fulfilling life without worrying about buying or selling art. my hunger is not satisfied with one concept of art like i would spend my life making pencil sketches, I've made a lot of charcoal and pencil stuff over the years. but i would never want to do it too make ends meet.
nklarow t1_j9tixr5 wrote
Your only insult is calling people cops. At this point it's just fun to see how angry you're getting.
Hunter62610 t1_j9tuphb wrote
I want to see the actual effort and interplay of man and machine. You asked for a story about a little robot's dream of going to space? Boring. You spent 3 days fleshing out the same prompt and writing in details, refining, illustrating, reading, ect? Awesome.
redroverdestroys t1_j9v3qr0 wrote
you want to censor people from posting content that you don't like
you get off on people not liking censorship
you are actually psychotic.
nklarow t1_j9v4fct wrote
Keep going, I'm getting my popcorn ready.
ArgentStonecutter t1_j9z13tc wrote
It could be argued that that's how it fell.
I was thinking more like Peter F. Hamilton's novel "Watching Trees Grow", or Fred Pohl's "Waiting for the Olympians".
Ok-Hunt-5902 t1_j9osnaw wrote
What about a post of telling ChatGPT your dream? I just did that yesterday lol